Reviews for Serendipity 3 in New York, NY
You need a reservation unless you want to put down your name leave for an hour and come back! It's a small place and was packed... when we went! The bacon Mac and cheese was amazing!!! My husband had the bacon BBQ burger and he enjoyed it!! You have to havethe frozen hot chocolate which they are known for it was also amazing, but definitely can be shared it is large!! Quick friendlyservice as well!! Read more
Average food, but amazing drinks and desserts. Granted I only got a foot long hot dog. Be prepared to share your meal if you... want to get a taste of everything. Shared meal, but not drinks and still wasn't able to get dessert. For adult non chocolatelovers the Irish white chocolate drink is amazing. Pictured is just the drinks! Read more
Love! love!! love!!! Their frozen hot chocolate ????????????. It was delicious the dessert, the waffles, the fries were all... great. Make sure to get a reservation just so you don't have to wait outside. Read more
To start, we had difficulty making reservations even 2 weeks in advance. We lucked out same day and scored an 11:45 pm... seating. The dining area was complete chaos with no social distance and a room full of sugar-high kids. Service was slow and themenu lacked variety beyond sundaes and frozen hot chocolate (milkshakes). My daughter ordered strawberries and cream, which wasa glass of syrup with a few strawberries, covered in whipped cream. It was about $15. Absurd. My husband’s apple pie (a lamode) was nearly frozen - delicious, but not warmed at all. Because it was so late, and cold, we hoped to get hot cocoa andcoffee…but bad news, the only hot drinks on the menu are tea. And the iced coffee we ordered was not sweetened, so theyoffered sugar separate, but it sure didn’t melt into the iced coffee. Just underwhelmed with our experience, as we expectedmore given all the hype. Read more
You and your kids will love this place! It’s a cute restaurant with a bunch of random decor that really adds a unique vibe.... Upon entering, we were greeted and taken care of by very kind waiters throughout our dining experience. The food is definitely abit pricier however, they are delicious. There’s a lot of hype over their desserts yet the food is just as great! The buffalochicken sandwich and the frozen white chocolate is worth the try! Portion is also very large and filling so expect to take someleft overs home. Everyone will have a great time here. From the food, to the service, all the way to the restaurant vibe,everything was a complete hit! Read more
I normally don't go to places just for dessert, but man this place was incredible. If you have a sweet tooth, come here. Plain... and simple! It's expensive I must admit, but well worth the price of admission. The freaking pecan pie is the best I've everhad, period. Come eat here, stop reading this and go eat some dessert trust me. Read more
Went there for my daughters 11th birthday after she requested a “fancy restaurant that sells burgers”. I made reservations... for 7pm. We arrived a few minutes early and didn’t have to wait long to be seated. The hostess was really nice. They ask forproof of vaccination at the door (including minors). We had Leslie as our waitress and she went above and beyond for us, shedefinitely made my daughters day extra special. Shout out to her! The food was amazing also! We all had a great time and willmake sure to be back again. Read more
Insanely delicious (and HUGE) frozen hot chocolate. Such a fun and cute atmosphere! You pay for the touristy piece a bit, but... it’s a great stop on your trip and just a bucket list place! Read more