Reviews for The Meatball Shop - Upper East Side in New York, NY
These are some amazing New York City meatballs! The vibes and service here were amazing. We went before a terminal 5 show so... there were other concert goers here too. The food is amazing all the meatballs combos are fun and the waitress helped us pick. Iwent with traditional Italian red sauce and beef meatballs, my wife got the chicken balls in Parmesan cream sauce. So good! thesquash risotto was creamy and perfect and the Brussel sprouts with pecans and sweet taste blew my mind love this place. Read more
Good food if you love meatballs , I was just a little disappointed they have a variety of choices but not turkey meatballs. So I... got the classic with spicy meat sauce and polenta. The others at my table enjoyed their meals also . Sangria was not the best. I would recommend this place . Just not necessarily on a weekend. Read more
Ooooo wee been waiting to try this place. It did not disappoint. Started with the Mini Buffalo Balls and WOW. I could eat 3... servings of those things. The Fig & Pig Flatbread was incredible. Bread was crisp and the balsamic glaze was the cherry on top.Ended up going with the Chicken Parm Parm w/ classic meatballs instead of the chicken meatballs. A+ and can’t wait to go back. Read more
This place was recommended by the concierge at our hotel and did not disappoint. It’s fairly small so if you really want to go... here, make a reservation. That being said, our food arrived VERY quickly so you’ll also probably be able to get in without areservation. We ordered the carafe of Chianti for $19 which I HIGHLY recommend, it was very high quality. My mom ordered thechicken pesto cavatappi which was delicious. There were at least 6-7 meatballs in it and the cheese was delicious. I ordered thekitchen sink which comes with your choice of meatballs and sauce with sides the chef picked. I will say, I was expecting thesides to be hot and they were cold but they were still really good. The side salad had a nice flavor, the carrots werecaramelized and the broccoli had nice seasoning. Our waiter, Hunter, was also very good and checked on us often. His attitudewas just so positive that it really rounded out the night. I would definitely come here again and recommend that you do as well! Read more
Delicious meatballs or perfect balls (vegan option available) and sides that you can build your own dish or just sample a... meatball on its own. We did a walk in on a Friday night and were seated right away. Great cocktails and drinks menu, served veryefficiently too. The servers are all super friendly and will make you feel very welcome. Read more
We love this place. Its a local favorite with tons of friendly faces. Both the large and small plates have a lot to offer. I do... not eat pork, so I was pleased to see a lot of chicken/beef/lamb options offered on their menu. Note: this is not a paid ad. Wewere shooting some images for a local news piece and the staff just welcomed us in! They even jumped in some photos with us!It’s so nice to see there are still amazing neighborhood restaurants you can find this kind of experience in. Read more
Visited this restaurant as part of our hell's kitchen food tour. As our tour guide said this is the only meatball place in... Hell's kitchen, so if you are in mood for meatballs then this is the place to go. Ambience is nice, service is descent. The porkand beef meatball with their marinara was the very good. Rest of the food, the buffalo chicken balls and the cauliflower wereok. Read more
Great place! They were very accommodating and allowed my small dog to have a seat inside. Loved the food! Our server was... attentive to all our requests. And loved the Halloween decor ???? definitely recommend this place for a late nightouting???????? Read more