Reviews for Panther Pizza & Bakery in Newark, OH
This year alone, I have ordered Panther Pizza over 20 times. From that, I feel very confident that I have a strong understanding... of the Panther Pizza brand and what they serve. Normally I spend around $25-30 per visit. Their food is seriously reallygood!!! Panther?s pepperoni and sauce is unmatched. It?s a unique taste that you seriously CANNOT find anywhere else. Thecookies are hit or miss depending on your taste, but my favorite thing on their menu is their cake. After a long annoying weekat work, their cake just hits the spot and makes life feel great until it?s gone. It should seriously be illegal that their cakeisn?t an option on their website. I?d order more if so. Now with that said, Panther has started to subcontract delivery throughDoorDash. A big appeal of Panther for me is that I could support the LV community by supporting a small business and by puttingtip money in the pockets of LV students. I graduated from LV and I want to support my people. I?ve personally never had apositive DoorDash experience before and I?ve lived in different states/cities. I order from Panther specifically so I won?t haveto use DoorDash or GrubHub because I almost always get food poisoning/cold food from those apps. It?s never worth the money. Iopened my door tonight and had a sketchy middle-aged man give me a pizza. My first thought was ?I?m glad I have securitycameras.? and not ?Let?s go! Pizza time!? When I tip ~50%, I want to support the LV community, not Meth Teeth Mike. I?m stillgoing to support Panther, but I?m just going to start ordering delivery through Dirkos instead when I?m not in the mood todrive. Dirkos is just nasty greasy bar food in comparison, but at least it shows up hot and you don?t feel unsafe afterwards. Read more
Never been disappointed with Panther Pizza untill tonight. Ordered our usual, BLT stromboli, and a stuffed crust pep, sausage,... mushroom. Stuffed crust ,on point, like always. BLT no toppings on 50% of the pizza. Not sure what happened......... Read more
We used to love this place, had a bad experience a few months ago and decided to try it again tonight. The amount of sauce on... the pizza makes it almost inedible. The cheese distribution (or lack thereof) is sad. The only good thing about the experiencetonight was the speed of the delivery. The owner and staff are very nice and the baked goods are on point. I?m not sure what hashappened to this place over the years but it?s unfortunate, the pizza just isn?t worth the money anymore. Read more
Amazing food, great prices, and awesome staff!!! The wings are absolamazing and i recommend the panther wing sauce! We also got... the meat pleaser and wow tons and tons of toppings!!!! Keep up the great work guys, youre doing great. Drove amost an hour justto try this place out and worth every second of the drive. Read more
Hands down, the BEST pizza I've ever eaten. The Chicago deep dish was amazing and the Krazy bread is awesome!
The same night I went in, it to was extremely busy! What can you expect on a saturday night ? The recent Chodeats group in... Facebook has created an explosion for this community and small businesses. Some of us traveling great distances to get theexperience. Regardless, I made my second trip to this wonderful family establishment to help support local business just today.Five days later. And I am not disappointed! The old saying goes " if you have nothing nice to say, dont say anything at all" Read more
If you've never has Panther Pizza, you must try it. Staff was super friendly and the food was absolutely amazing. They had free... samples of the BLT stromboli, omg i cannot wait to order a whole one next time! So yummy. Read more
Panther Pizza is some of the best pizza I've ever eaten! Noelle has a knack for developing unique pizzas such as her Elite which... is my all time favorite! You can taste the love she puts into her pizzas! Noelle's personality is contagious...if you meet heryou'll find out why her business is thriving! Read more