Reviews for Pizza Cottage in Newark, OH
Food is really really good. Order accuracy is really really bad. Over the years we?ve had about 50% accuracy. Once we got home... and the pizza had no cheese at all on it! Employees just don?t seem to care. I?ve talked to managers several times. They giveme gift certificates and I tell them I don?t need gift certificates. I need them to address the accuracy issue with theiremployees but it never gets better. Will quit going to the Newark store and drive the extra distance to Zanesville from now on! Read more
Was a great place for my nephew Layton Sheppard's 13th birthday party. Hard to believe he is a teenager already!! Skylar... Alestock put together a really birthday ???? party ???? Great memories that can & will be looked back on. -blh Read more
Service was great and pizza was Awesome! Our server Savannah was truly a very sweet polite young lady Thank You Savannah!! I... highly recommend Cottage Pizza to anyone Read more
The steak sub was huge but was a hamburger patty. Ok, but too much mayo. Fries were good. Prices and service were good. Took a... star away as my the food did not sit well. Read more
Pizza Cottage is a Central Ohio institution. They serve top quality and delicious pizza every single time. The atmosphere is... always low key, relaxed, and the service is always quick and friendly. They don?t skimp on toppings, and we never have to worryabout leaving there any other way but stuffed to the gills! Our only ?complaint? is that delivery would be a welcomed option.However, nothing beats fresh-out-of-the-oven pizza right when it?s made. Love this place! Read more
Pizza Cottage has gone down hill and gotten really expensive for bad pizza. We used to really like them but didn't go very often... because they were on the more expensive side. This time we ended up with two small pizzas that were gross and a mostly lettucesalad for $43. Not worth it and extremely disappointing. My pizza was a small gluten free cauliflower crust that was burnedblack on the edge and under done chewy in the center. I was up charged $5 for being gluten free and they ruined the crust. Saveyour money and go somewhere else. Read more
I love this pizza joint! The crust is thin and crispy and the cheese is extra stringy! The restaurant itself is clean and open.... They have an area set aside for the bar. The prices are good. The bread sticks are a little think for me, but the marinara saucewas awesome! Read more
Never had problems love the staff no matter the wait your getting the best food its worth the visit great place to watch sports... its just a perfect place all around Read more