Reviews for The Incredible Pizza Co in Newark, OH
This is the place I've been looking for, so stop your Google search here. When other places close these lovely people cater to... those that work odd hours, who want pizza after 10pm in Newark this is your place! Buy 2 subs get the 3rd free and they'redelicious, pizza buy one get one the same size $4 more! Please check menus as prices may be subject to change but I'm incrediblyhooked on the incredible pizza place you will be too! Don't forget to tip your driver. Read more
There is a reason buy one pizza get one for 4 dollars. That being said the subs are fairly good, especially the Italian and... Philly cheese steak. Read more
We ordered two Italian subs and one meatball sub. We got three Italian subs and all of them were drenched in dressing and... soggy. Pizza didn't have enough sauce and was dry. Delivery time was great for a Friday night and the staff was superfriendly. Overall we won't be ordering from here again Read more
Only place open after 9:00 pm in the Newark area. All other restaurants think it's still Covid Shut Down and does not think... anyone needs to eat after 9pm. Great staff of workers, pretty good food, as I have tried most of the menu. Great Potato Skins Read more
Got pizza was cussed out by the driver because we were having card issues tried to take back the food we tried to pay for and... said they get prank calls all the time he didn?t have time for this. Very rude guy. Said all the food that is left over theowner has to eat all of it that we shouldn?t have called to get food. Such a great place to get food ???????????????? Read more
This place goes thru phases. Sometimes its good food, hot, cooked right, delivered fast! Sometimes its not! Undercooked or... sitting under a hot lamp waiting for the rest of the order to finish, slow drivers w 2 hr wait times :( It is the ONLY place intown to get food till 4am and the Owner tries his best to get help to work for 9 bucks an hr? Ugh.... Roll the Dice? Read more
I work the graveyard shift so when I need dinner they are open. This last time I ordered I was terribly disappointed as I order... quite a bit from there. Food was so cold, I can't have red sauce and the sauce was covered on my bread like it exploded. Fooddidn't come with mayo like I asked. Only good thing was I had a soda to wash it down. The manager is very nice and that's why Irated the way I did. He gave me store credit which I wouldn't even know what to order again but he tried. When I ordered my foodthe lady who took my order didn't know the menu well and even cussed on the phone. Which I get it it happens . But yeah keepimproving and just try to do your best hopefully my next order will be better ?? Read more
Thanks for the great subs. Only place to get great subs. Thanks