Reviews for Domino's Pizza in Newburgh, IN

The best Domino's in the tri-state area! Fast, friendly service every time!

I order from this Domino?s a ridiculous number of times in any given time period and have for a number of years. The output... from this location is above all else quality and consistent. My biggest gripe was that any sauces for my order wouldn?t arrivewith my order- even if I put a note in the delivery notes box. Management explained it was a flaw with how their systemprinted out orders, but I can say this issue has seemingly resolved itself and I?ve not had this be an issue for awhile now. Their drivers are prompt and friendly. If there was ever an issue with an order, management always made it right whether with anew delivery or store credit. I?m a night owl and appreciate their later delivery times when nothing around me for 15+ milesis still open, they have been there too save the day. Highly recommend this location in particular and Domino?s in general. Read more

Every time I call to order pizza, they answer right away and already know my name and what I ordered last time. Very efficient... and makes it so nice. I get tired of ordering from papa John?s and Pizza Hut and you have to be on hold and then you are talkingto some foreigner at their headquarters office that you can?t hardly understand. Dominos all the way! Read more

Times are approximate. Consistently good food. I feel like the app/website aggressively promise unrealistically short times... (but within about 5-10 minutes of actual prep times). This shop's kitchen is tiny, so it makes sense that they might back upeasier. We've not had an excessive delay in recent years. The food is consistently good and made at or above Domino's brandstandards. Read more

Out walking in my neighborhood that has a speed limit of 20 mph and a Domino's delivery driver flew by going at least 40 mph.... There were kids riding their bikes in the street. Absolutely unacceptable. Driver was male with long hair driving a truck. WhenI flagged him down to slow down he stopped, got out and yelled "You're willing to die to slow me down?!" I will never orderpizza from the Newburgh Domino's again. Read more

I've been a customer of the Newburgh Indiana Domino's for 12 years. I place an order at least twice a month or more for the... last 12 years. I always tip the drivers. I also have always paid in a check. Never have I ever bounced a check. So if you do themath for 12 years at least twice a month that's a lot of money The othe day I placed an order and they no longer take checks. Ifelt offended I'd always been a great customer. They will never get anymore business from me. Read more

Worst ever, not a huge shocker for this location! I called in and ordered curbside because the app crashed on me. The girl on... the phone was rude and pushy. Waited outside for 35 minutes before calling and asking if my order was ready when she told methey don't do curbside over the phone? Ok? So my order sat there and got cold. Back at the hotel, no surprise cold pizza, coldand oddly tasting undercooked wings. When I said I was done with Subway, I meant it...never went back and won't. Now I can saythe same thing for Domino's. Never ordering from them again. I'm just done! Read more

Tonight we spent over $40 for our order and got bad service and bad food. We did not get all the items we ordered and had to ga... back to get it. Then we get home and see the pizza we ordered "well done" looks barely cooked (first pizza.) When I called thestore I was told they would send me another pizza, which is the burnt trash in the second picture. Even the delivery guy wasshaking his head. The recording when you call the store says "we appreciate your business." I call bull$hit. Read more