Reviews for Fat Boy's Pizza Newburgh in Newburgh, IN

Medium stroms were way too hot. Mild stroms tasted like sloppy Joe. Pizza is good though

Wow!!! I got a half Strom and breadsticks. It was FIRE!! SOOOO GOOD! I had to save the other half of my Strom and the Stix for... later. I was full. They don't skimp on filling, bread was buttered and perfectly toasted. Great service great food! Thisplace will be my weekly guilty pleasure. ???? Read more

First time trying today. We loved it. Has a sweeter sauce and absolutely perfect crispy crust. Didn't skimp on cheese or... toppings. Definitely trying again. Good price for what you get as well. Read more

This is the first time my husband and I tried their pizza. Absolutely one of the best in town! The crust is thin but has a chew... to it, which I love! They load it with toppings and real mozzarella cheese, but that sauce! Omgsh, I don't know what they do toit, but it's incredible! I highly recommend their pizza! It's outstanding, and if you have read my reviews, I rarely state that.Unbeatable flavor and toppings! I'm just so shocked that it has beat the others by far!! We're definitely getting our pizza herefrom here on! Great job, Fat Boy's ????????????! Read more

GREAT SUPER DELICIOUS HOT WINGS AND SUPER SCRUMPTISHOLUS PIZZA???? JUST LOOK AT THOSE PICTURES! As a matter of fact, I'm going... to order again today ???? Read more

Always delicious. Better stroms than Pizza King in my opinion and they're less than $6 on Tuesdays. Ham and cheese sandwich and... chicken bacon ranch sandwich are also fabulous. The chicken bacon ranch can get a bit messy but it's totally worth it. Supernice people, too. Read more

Ok on the thin pizza scale of 10 being Spankeys and 1 Cici's. We had the Meat Lovers, Pepperoni, and Buffalo Wings. I give it a... 7-1/2 to 8. The pizza sauce is a flavorful tomatoe base . The toppings were hardy, and the cheese is very tasty. The cheese tomeat ratio is adequate and they don't skimp on the amount of either that they load onto the pizza. The wings were baked and havea spicy, but not hot sauce. Overall, the experience was very good with Great customer service. Read more

Loved the pizza! The crispness in the crust was absolutely perfect! Bee. Wanting to try their pizza for a while. I recommend if... you love delicious pizza that you try this immediately. Friendly staff, small location so it is not dine-in. I ordered pepperoniand beef. The ingredients tasted very fresh. 5 stars! Read more