Loading

Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Newcastle, OK

Patricia McGee 1 year ago
1

Rude employees who obviously do not have any idea about customer service!! Ordered a pappadia with bbq chicken extra onions and... no cheese, and the rude employee could not make it that way!?!?! I?ve gotten that same order at the Newcastle locationbefore!!!! Read more

Angelo Capozi 1 year ago
2

About done with papa johns Order was compketly wrong and tge already pizza has literally no sauce Spent $75 and only ate the... breadsticks Tried calling and nobody answers the phone And don't blame staffing there was 6 people working Read more

Dragonstone Gem & Ironworks Crawford 1 year ago
5

Pizza is pizza right; until it's pepperoni stuffed crust from this pizzeria! So the young lady was extraordinarily nice totally... helpful and had a top shelf sence of humor! Papa John's clone her quick b4 she gets away! I'm pretty much a guy who likes pizzaas long as the crust isn't crunchy. This was perfect! Even though it was supposed to be Alfredo sauce no tomatoes and wasn't, Idid not complain. It was very good and cooked exactly right! Don't blame the young lady at all. My cohort in crime and I werecutting up with her extensively! So yes, if ever I were back in this neck of the woods, you betcha I'll revisit. Ifin you arearound there, what are you waiting for? You KNOW you want pepperoni stuff crust now! Read more

Vic Ph 2 years ago
1

Absolutely the worst pizza experience of my life. The sign on the door says ?Veteran Owned? - well the owner should be... embarrassed and ashamed of the service provided at their establishment. Get your pizza elsewhere if you actually want to eat. Read more

Jerry Wadlow 2 years ago
1

I ordered pizza and asked for it to be delivered they said it would be 45 to 55 min. After 1 hr and 15 min I called them and was... told I didn't make any order. I was passed because I had already paid. I called back and they found my order but they haven'tmade it because they are 3 hrs behind. That was my first and last time dealing with Papa Johns Read more

Jimmy L 2 years ago
5

I pass through here every so often and they always produce great quality pizza. I always pick up single pizzas so I'm not sure... about delivery or any other product they offer. Friendly service every visit also. Read more

Gail King 2 years ago
1

Delivery was great, bread sticks and supreme pizza were good, but..Daaaaannngg!!! What's up with the sauce on the Philly cheese... steak pizza?!?! Tasted like sour mayonnaise slathered all over the crust. It was so terrible we actually threw the entire pizzaout. (No, I don't have COVID-19 and never had it. Taste buds are fine). Read more

Scott Amy 4 years ago
1

The pizza is honestly good but if I'm paying $45 for two pizzas I expect to get them delivered to me 5 miles away less than an... hour after getting out of the oven. Almost half the time I get a call looking for my location. The last time, and I mean itwill be the last time, after three calls still no sign of the pizza. I called the store manager and got no resolution other than"I guess they're looking for you". I called the driver to send it back. There needs to be some training for the drivers and forlocal management on customer relations. I will find another pizza restaurant that works a bit harder and has a better attitudefor their customers. Update. Take anything that Christina Simmons said about this place ?doing a 180? with a grain of salt. She?s the general manager who emailed me about my experience, invited me to call to discuss my experience and, after leaving amessage on her cell, hasn?t returned my call or bothered to follow up in any manner after two weeks. The problems thisparticular location is experiencing seem to be systemic. Read more