Reviews for Joey Garlics' Newington in Newington, CT
This was my first time here iam from Ohio my wife's family is from Connecticut and I can say this place was AMAZING!! The pizza... were awsome not over priced fresh topping. So many different styles and flavors to chose from .we all got different small orpersonal sized and shared peace . With turn out to be enough for 5 of us with some to take home. DEFIANTLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACEIF UR IN CONNECTICUT Read more
Stopped here for dinner, no wait got seated nice a quickly. Comfortable and clean booths. Nice servers. Food was fantastic. Def... highly recommend Read more
Everyone has their own preferences when it comes to pizza but i think i set the bar pretty high coming from the New Haven and... Valley area. For me, this is the best pizza in town. And i love Joey Garlic's meatballs. My only criticism is when they getbusy, their take out personnel really struggle to keep things straight. No one should ever arrive at the restaurant and find outthey didnt even put your order in. Dinner tonight was very good. Service good as well. What was a disappointment were themeatballs. They were rubbery. First time i had disappointing meatballs here. We split a Meatball Salad tonight as an appetizer. Read more
35 minute wait on Friday night. Had a drink at the bar as we waited. Good atmosphere and service. Pizza a little under cooked,... still, very good. Hamburg, raw onions, 1/2 Artichoke Hearts. Side of fries, very good Read more
This was my second time here. I wasn't sure what to get, there's so much variety and selection in the menu, the last time I was... here, I had a white pizza, this time I had a chicken ceaser wrap with a side of french fries and as always the food was great,fresh and nicely prepared. The drinks were also delicious. This place has become one of my favorite restaurants. Can't wait toreturn. Read more
The Penne Alla Vodka was so good, but the portion was too big for my liking. The pizza was really good too. The servers are nice... also. If you enjoy big portions of pasta then I reccommend coming here. Read more
This place I will definitely be going to again. It was a very affordable place for what you were getting. I went here with my... family and the food was delicious, the service was awesome and you get very big portions. When me and my family went, we gotfour big potions for only 85.46! I got the Chicken Parm with soup and a side of pasta and it was really big. And the three otherportions that my family got were just as big. We came home with a lot of leftovers. Definitely coming here again! Highlyrecommend to anyone! Read more
My husband and I went I for dinner on 10/07/22 great food however, my husband asked for sausage pizza it actually was served... without the sausage and so we send it back waited an additional 20 minutes, waitress brought over to us and what they literallydid just throw cold and sausage over it, absolutely grossed. In addition, we thought they will give us sausage pizza fresh outof the oven but they didn’t it. Not a great experience. Lazy chef. Read more