Reviews for Castle John's Newmarket in Newmarket, ON
Not for me, but I'm willing to try again. I ordered a castle burger with fries and some samosas through SkipTheDishes. Prices... seemed fair. Their menu had variety, which I was happy to see. Everything sounded so good! The meal preparation was fast and itwas delivered in less than the estimated time because of that. First thing I tried were the fries, which I enjoyed quite a bit.The burger had a toothpick in it to keep it together in transit, which is better than some other restaurants. However, I foundthe burger patty to be too overcooked for my liking, and it tasted pretty bland, so I wouldn't recommend it. I felt a bit illafter eating it as well. The samosas and sweet chili sauce were good. The service was quick and efficient but the food didn'timpress me. I might return someday to try something different on the menu, because the positive reviews gave me high hopes and Iwant to give them another chance, but I won't be recommending it to friends. If the owner responds to reviews, what dish wouldyou recommend I try? Read more
I got the full rack of ribs and fish taco for take out and the ribs were the best I?ve ever had! The bones fell right off the... bone, and the fish tacos were super fresh and crispy!!!! I recommend castle John to anyone looking for high quality meal for agood price! Read more
Food was really good and service was excellent. Apps and main came in a timely manner.
Thursday Wing and chip special is amazing. Large portions. Delicious wings. Fresh fries. The other plate is lobster pasta. To... die for. Beers on tap are great/fresh/large glasses. Great service. Nice decor, TV screens look amazing and the pool tables arefun. Can't wait to return and try more food. Read more
Castle John's was a lovely experience. The atmosphere is nice and the food is fantastic! I had the 1lb wing deal and added a... small Buffalo Chicken Poutine to my order. My friend ordered the Chicken Parmasean. It was very difficult to choose what toorder as there are so many amazing dishes on the menu! Cannot wait to try more! My waitress was very pleasant and attentive. Iwill definitely be back to Castle John's soon! Read more
This is a favourite place for us and the take out is great too. Food is fresh and presentation is great. My husband loves the... chicken wings, I have always enjoyed the salads and stirfrys. Tastes just like homemade. Read more
This restaurant is amazing. I ordered take out for a party and the food was well presented and everyone loved the food as it was... fresh and tasty. I would recommend trying this place out. My dine in experience was also amazing, there was a wide range on themenu and their service was efficient. This will definitely be my go to spot. Read more
Came here for the first time with my boyfriend and overall it was a good experience and I would definitely come back. The only... 2 suggestions that I have is to ensure that the appetizers are served before the main is served. My chicken wings were nice andsaucy when they arrived to me, but unfortunately by the time I started eating them, they were as dry and hard as a rock, becauseI was eating the appetizer first. Additionally, it would be nice to have the option to turn off the TV at your table becauseit's quite a distraction when you're trying to have a conversation with the people you're with. Otherwise, the poutine andperogies tastes really good. Read more