Reviews for Papa John's Pizza in Newmarket, ON
Delicious and be good customer service. It was not a planned stop, but it is a new pizza place that I will return to.
The sides were tasty, but honestly, not a huge fan of the pizza. I find the sauce to be a little bit too sweet it?s very sugary... for my taste, but to each their own. Read more
Ordered ultimate stuffed crust pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. Got something that tasted like Dr. Oetker frozen pizza. No... stuffed crust. Barely eney cheese. Just sad! Read more
Personally, I love the pizza of Papa John's. Their pizza satisfies my cravings, everytime. Moreover, the staff is really very... good. They are so kind. Read more
Decided to try PJ as they had a promotion for 50% off online orders, very nice pizza. Dough cooked well, not greasy. They add... pepper and garlic dip in each order. Read more
Bought garlic Parmesan bread sticks to go with a soup I?d made and they were delicious! Order size is very generous as the... photo shows and they reheat beautifully the next day. Read more
While I love the taste of Papa John's pizza and I like how a garlic dip is included, the toppings are not very generous. I've... ordered from here several times and it seems every time there isn't enough quantity of toppings. Otherwise I would have given it5 stars. Read more
I forgot his name but he was the nicest staff we have ever seen. There were three of us and there were only two chairs and he... kindly got us a chair. It was nice of him to prioritize us because he knew we were students and that we had a very limited lunchtime and he understood. Thank you so much Read more