Loading

Reviews for The Maids Cottage in Newmarket, ON

Kira MacDonald 1 year ago
5

Best butter tarts ever!! Love that I can order online and pick up. Tons of homemade meals and delicious baked goods. Quick and... friendly service! They rent out the dining space in the back for events too which is really nice. Read more

nick callicapa 1 year ago
3

You know, I just can't seem to understand this place completely. They are open for limited times and not on any Sundays too (I... would guess they would make good money on Sundays right down on the main st?) Then they still aren't allowing anyone to eatinside their place still? Only takeout and outside seem strange still. On a plus note, they do sell a great butter tart still. Read more

Alnoor Kara 1 year ago
5

Best butter tarts I?ve ever had. Pecan has become my favourite flavour after having it here. No wonder it won the award for... best butter tart. It is worth the drive! Read more

Nina 1 year ago
5

The pecan butter tarts that we had for a breakfast with coffee was a amazing. These pecan tarts are so GOOD, a definite must... try.???? Read more

Gina Tirabassi 1 year ago
5

Today we celebrated my future daughter-in-law's bridal shower at The Maids Cottage. The owner Deb and her staff were very... accommodating from the on start. The brunch was a hit with the guests with a huge selection including vegan, gluten free andcooked to perfection by chef Victor. Victor created a masterpiece with the fruit platter. The venue was recently renovated witha modern style to suit any event decor. Thank you Deb, Kathleen, Victor, Barb, Pam and Steve (sound tech) for making it apleasurable experience. Read more

Rod Turple 1 year ago
5

Warm welcomes and kind smiles to greet you. The tarts are sweet, which helps make them not get all gobbled up at once. I bought... half a dozen and could only eat 2 at first. The price is more than most other places, but the quality is well worth double theprice. The variety of different flavors is amazing; something for everyone. I will return before heading home. Read more

Connors Music 2 years ago
5

We participated in an Easter Scavenger Hunt hosted by Jennifer Jones group realty and a half dozen butter tarts had to follow me... home. They certainly lived up to their reputation as I've heard nothing but legendary reviews of their butter tarts! ThanksMaid's Cottage for helping bring a winning dessert to Easter! :) Read more

Pither Temoteo 2 years ago
5

Finally, I had the chance to try the famous butter tarts from The Maid's Cottage. It is simply delicious. It is worth it to... cross the city. The tarts are really special, taste so good, so fresh. Definitely, it is the best butter tart ever. All thedifferent flavors make it even better. The lady who works there is such a nice person. The only problem is that the store is toobusy, but I understand. Everyone wants the same nice things as me. Nice places usually are very busy. Read more