Reviews for Buscemi's Pizza in Newport, MI
This is the 2nd time in a month we ordered pizza. Both times it has been the most delicious pizza, cooked to perfection.
Usually it's very good service. It's summer and a Friday night, their website says their open until 11 and I call to order at... 10. The only thing I hear when I call is, "Hello, we're closed." And the call disconnects. Must be nice to have a job thatcloses when you decide it does. Read more
Called at 9:30 and they said they weren't taking any more orders, but y'all are open until 11? Anyways we called the other... location on Monroe Street (this location told us they wouldn't take our order either) and they sounded absolutely perplexed thatthis location was already closing down an hour and a half before close and they'd totally take our order AND the delivery driverdidn't even mind coming all the way out to where we were (ya know cause we tried the one closest to us and they wouldnt take ourorder.) Hmm. Strange. Anyways won't be getting our business anymore. Super rude. Read more
We ordered pizza to pick up. We showed up to get it only to find out they ?forgot to put one of them in the oven.? No apologies... or attempt to make it right. I?d understand if it were busy, but it wasn?t. And they still couldn?t be bothered with a simple?I?m sorry? Read more
Really good pizza with a nice simple sauce and a great dense puffy crust. Good cheese, sausage was spicy but super good! Cheesey... bread was also really good, had a nice buttery garlic flavor! Read more
My pizza was wrong. The website says they are open for another hour. They are closed. I can't fix the problem. My pizza was... ordered with Cheese, feta cheese, green olives, mushrooms and banana peppers. No cheese at all, no banana peppers. It'sinedible cardboard and I am surprised. They have never done this. Read more
If you're an anti-masker and like mediocre pizza, this might be the place for you. I, on the other hand, prefer the common... decency of wearing a mask around other people... and mediocre pizza. All employees that I could see in there were maskless, so Iwon't be going back. There's more mediocre pizza 3 minutes down the road. Read more
Friendly and fast service, great pizza everytime.