Reviews for Pig Whistle Inn in Newton, NJ
I?m 6 months pregnant & have been craving mozzarella sticks.. someone told my husband to take me here and for that - I?m very... grateful LOL - the best mozzarella sticks I?ve ever had in my entire life. They are like something that you?d see in a viralsocial media post on a food page. I?m not usually someone to want to hang outside by a band but the band was really great and itwas such a casual, fun atmosphere. Service was great, they admitted they were short staffed and training someone (her first day)but between the two of them they kept everyone happy & fed! Pulled pork was delicious, fries were hand cut and fresh. The onlything I left mad about was not coming here sooner!!! Read more
stopped in for lunch today. the wings were out of this world. friendly and kind bartender. neat atmosphere inside, outside... looked even better. will absolutely come back! the owner should be proud, keep up the great work. Read more
Cold food. Slow service. Small/overpriced portions. Hair in meat. ----- I'd like to believe that my friends & I came on a "bad... day." All of our food was cold upon arrival and the appetizer portions (Nachos & Fried Pickle chips) are **SMALL** for thecost. Service was also very slow. We ordered pulled pork and ribs. The meat was cooked well but was cold upon arrival.Additionally the BBQ sauce was very sweet without much flavor. One of us found hair in the pulled pork. The corn bread was verydry. I have eaten at other BBQ places in the region. For the cost, we could have gotten higher quality food & more reasonableportions at other nearby establishments Read more
I was in the area and had had a need for BBQ. Did a Google search on maps and to my surprise found this place. It was in an... area I would not think a restaurant would be. Residential. I took a drive over, parked and went down toward the backyard. Iwanted sit outside and found the entire backyard was the restaurant. We ordered and enjoyed watching the orders coming out forother tables. It all looked so good. Our order came and enjoyed our selections. Everything was very tasty. There was amusician on a stage singing country music. Not really a fan but he was good. The prices was about what you would expect forBBQ. Went home with a smile on my face. I definitely will stop in again when I'm in the area. Read more
The food is awesome! Great BBQ! The signature drink was delicious! My husband burger had lots of bacon. The wings are literally... the best wings I have ever had. The brisket was delicious! Also, the cheesecake tastes completely homemade! Loved everything!Our waitress Sarah was cheerful and awesome! I love the outside atmosphere! Great kids menu! My family was happy! I wasdefinitely happy! I will definitely be back! Read more
Great local restaurant with good food. Small but cozy interior.. Their brisket is really good and have a good variety of wings... selection with a lot of dry rub options. Would definitely recommend if you are in the area or living close by. Read more
Finally came to check out the Pig Whistle Inn with friends after going to the Christmas market at the Fairgrounds today. We... were told that it is very common that the 'Pig' was often out of a number of items at their bar / food menu, which in theirexperience included ice, beer varieties and food items.... but they had good wings. Boy did we have a good laugh when ourserver told us they had no draft beer or bourbon/whiskey or one of the special drinks, because of a party they had the nightbefore - pulled pork either. What bar runs out of bourbon?? So we ordered 2 flavors of wings and 4 burgers, both of which werevery good, but the tray they came on were ice cold and so were the buns. Our server was very pleasant and the atmosphere wascomfortable. Giving three stars because of the history of not having items and delivering on that legacy. Can't decide ifwe'll go back. Read more
Great local family-run bbq place. Excellent wings with tasty dry rub. Rubs fell off the bone and the meat was tender. Fried... pickles were good too! Very casual atmosphere and friendly staff. I will be back soon! Read more