Reviews for Mario's Pizza in Niagara Falls, NY
It's tough living in NYC and having to review pizza outside of the area... Marios has an efficient staff, indoor seating,... outdoor seating, but...not the best pizza. Sauce and crust weren't the best. Pizza itself may be 4-5/10 but the prices were alsohigher than expected. I understand this is a tourst area, so the prices will be higher...but $12 for two slices and a 20oz.soda....definitely not worth it in my opinion. I know buying by the slice may not be the best...maybe others may have betterluck with buying a fresh pie. Read more
This pizza crust was thin and gummy- not cooked properly. The sauce was weak and has no flavor. I couldn?t order the toppings I... wanted on their menu because they didn?t have them, and their house chicken salad was unavailable as well. They only seems tohave a few things and I was very dissatisfied with w their pizza. Read more
I loved it. Definitely better fresh. We got the 18 inch pizza and ate all but 2 slices. I'd definitely come here again. I wish... we had a Mario's in Arizona. You definitely have to eat these with this signature pizza fold. This particular location smalland was packed everyone outside had pizza even with other food places around. Read more
Not the greatest pizza for New York style! Way over priced for quality. 3.5 stars
Outstanding NY style pizza, and even better after a day of checking out one of the most awesome natural wonders in the world,... Niagara Falls. Highly recommended. Read more
Great pizza, reasonable price. Best in the area with nice outdoor seating. Tried the Papa Johns across the road? scary!
Had ordered cheese pizza slice. The crust was neither thick nor thin . It was perfect ! Classic new york style pizza ???? ... Definitely must try when in niagara . Read more
Service was fast and the staff were happy to help. Small pizzeria with indoor and outdoor seating. About 5-6 small 2 top... tables for indoor seating. Great tasting NY style pizza. $3-$5 per slice and $24-$27 per whole pie. Their veggie, cheese, andHawaiian are great choices. Read more