Reviews for Penny Hill Bar and Char in Norman, OK
This is normally a pretty good place for lunch. Today, we had a new server who really should look into another line of work. Not... only did he get our order wrong (he had to return to the table three times to ask us what we had ordered), but then he gave uschecks that were not accurate. We paid them. Then he caught us as we were walking out the door to tell us we had to come backand pay more! A whole $4. I am happy to pay what I owe, but if you screw up the customer?s check and they pay, then the error ison you. So we spoke with the owner about the poor service. She was apologetic and gave us the lunches for free. (I would havegladly paid in full.) That?s the only reason I did not rate them any lower. Read more
I have enjoyed Penny Hill at least a 1/2 dozen times, especially the green chili burger, until my visit today. Expecting the... same high quality I've received before, I was totally disappointed. The cook apparently took the "char" to heart and prepared myburger the same way. I've never had a crispy burger before and I hope that was my last. I won't quietly consume inedible foodagain and will have to think hard about returning. Today's date 9/26/22 should be noted by the mgmt and someone talk to thelunch cook on duty. Explain to him crunchy burgers aren't generally considered delicious. Read more
A great menu with lots of choices and all the food is good. They are thought to have the best sweet potato fries! I enjoy a... broccoli cheddar baked potato almost every time I go. I also love the nachos. Generous servings very reasonable prices. Oh andeverybody loves their Cubano! Read more
Like the atmosphere, wait staff was great. Fun place to visit just don't go if you want a burger cooked less than well done. ... The cook staff is incapable of this feat. Manager present was not very seasoned and had numerous excuses by the second welldone burger ( ordered medium rare). Don't feel it is unrealistic to expect something cooked within one level of doneness whenyour paying 13.00 for the burger. This is my only, though significant complaint. Read more
I go just for the Ahi tuna sandwich. It is seared and less than cooked through, just like it should be. Fantastic! The rest of... their menu is solid all over. The owners are food people more than bar owners, but I never complained about their pours,either. Try the pan roasted green beans. I have never had beans like them at any other place. The spuds are huge. The burgersare creative. I love the French dip! It?s all good! Read more
Been here a few times, and the service was excellent; they were fast and awesome, but this time it was awful. I had Greg as a... server, and I had to ask him three times just for water. Then he brought out the wrong food, and I had to wait 5 minutes to getmy food. Then I tried to call him over for over 10 minutes to get my check and boxes. I had to YELL across the bar to get hisattention so we could get the bill and leave. It still gets two stars because every other time was great. Read more
Fun Sports themed bar and grill. Many beers on tap or in bottle. Great, friendly staff. Bar mini menu, and standard menu... selections available. Read more
Love Penny Hill! The atmosphere just draws you in soon as you walk through the door. All the staff a very friendly. Our waiter... was very attentive, he made sure we had full glasses and our food was brought to the table in record time. The beef fajitas areDeeelicious! We've been there quite a few times and have never been disappointed. Read more