Reviews for Horseneck Tavern in North Caldwell, NJ
I met with several of my friends there to hear Lenny and his music and enjoy a few craft beers. Lenny is the draw and is there... every other Friday from about 5pm until 10 or 11. HT offers a handful of craft drafts and a nice assortment of quality cannedbrews. I haven't eaten there but the menu looks good. Chris is a jovial host and the guys behind the bar are great. I'llcertainly be be back in 2 weeks with my regular group of friends. Read more
Ate here about a month ago with my girlfriend, we ordered a crab cake meal and crab cake smelled like rotten feet. I never... complain about food but asked if we could get a different dish in replace of that. Manager (or owner, not sure what he was) thenargued that the crab was supposed to smell that way and complained about us loudly to the kitchen staff. been here 3 timesprior and food was great, understandable that mistakes happen but being rude on top of serving foul food and then trying to sayit is supposed to smell foul is a little ridiculous. Will not go here again. Read more
We really enjoyed everything here at this scratch kitchen restaurant. Driven by a few times but never went in and now I know... what we've been missing. Service was great and so was ambiance. Read more
Loved the food and service was amazing. The kids loved it too. The chicken wings- mouth watering. Today I had the Tuna Tartare... special and it was delicious!! The bartender Darren is top notch! Best service, makes the best Fresno Margarita. Lastly thefresh pretzel and New Orleans style beignets ...yum. It's all good! Read more
I don’t know why I didn’t dine here earlier! I’ve driven past it so many times. I have to say, it was sooo good. The food... is yummy, the atmosphere both indoors and outdoors are very welcoming and the staff is just amazing. They have a full bar! Makesure to ask for Darren or Brian, their services are incredible. I will be back for sure! Read more
Everything was very well cooked and delicious! I had the grilled octopus salad, fish and chips, mushrooms and asparagus. You can... definitely share the sides. Read more
Pros: amazing drinks and bartenders are fantastic. Great ambiance and good people at the bar. Manager is also a great guy. Cons:... Food really sucks. I have been here multiple times and it is consistently a disappointment. If they got a new chef who couldcook the place would be amazing. Salmon bland and tasteless, fish tacos come with a tiny little piece of fish and the tortillais cold, and the burger is dry and tasteless (ordered medium). Friends feel the same way. Stick with drinks and the pretzel.Chef can’t mess that up. Read more
Really nice selection of food and cocktails. Enjoyed their brunch. Everyone was very friendly and attentive.