Reviews for Fingerhut Bakery in North Judson, IN
so many fond memories of Cicero Il location .. Babis Rye, Salty Horns , Coffee Cake, houska, kolache prune poppyseed and cheese... we?re always my favorites . i wished they would ship online again . The did make great butter cookies i member as a kid . now ihave to make my own kolache and it?s labor intensive Read more
Love this cafe and bakery! Home cooking, generous portions, reasonable prices and friendly service and cozy atmosphere.
Best bakery around! Always has a good selection and good prices. Friendly service
This place was absolutely fantastic! Lunch was first rate. I also got some donuts and bagels from the bakery. I wish I didn't... live 250 miles away; I'd eat here all the time. Read more
I feel guilty but not guilty for eating all these pastries by myself. They were super delicious. The best paczkis I have ever... had. I?m loving it! ???????? Read more
My Young Beautiful Bride and I were out for a Saturday morning drive, and we just happened to be traveling through North Judson,... Indiana. We found this little Fingerhut Bakery and thought about stopping in for a visit. The Young Lady was just the mostwonderful, helpful and thoughtful person, you'd ever want to meet. We bought a few things and snacked on them as we continuedour travels. We will definitely be visiting this place again whenever we are in the neighborhood. Read more
The eclairs were amazing! So much pudding and chocolate! And this caramel apple coffee cake?. O.M.G. Please keep this all year!... I went at closing so there wasn?t a lot of options left but we also tried the blueberry donut, it was just ok. Prices wereexcellent! Next I want to try the cookies and hopefully some more of the donuts! Read more
Great place. Really nice people. Good ol Hoosier hospitality. ???????? I give it a ten.