Reviews for Turiello's Pizza House in Nyack, NY
For those of us who grew up knowing that the best pizza always comes from generations of local Italian families, this is ?the... place?! A perfect ?Old School? pizzeria that never fails to deliver delicious piping hot authentic pizza pies. Whether by theslice or a full spread of cheesy deliciousness, you?ll always leave satisfied. Their melt-in-your-mouth meatballs are huge andoutrageously good! I also love the refreshing Black Cherry Soda. We go out of our way to eat there. If we lived any closer, itwould be my go-to lunch place? and that would be dangerous for my waistline! Sometimes street parking is a pain, but it?sdefinitely worth it! Read more
BEST PIZZA & WINGS IN NYACK!!! The pizza here is light delicious crispy. I wish I can rate this 10/10 always my go to for eats.
I?ve lived in proximity to this joint for most of my life I?ve still yet to find a pizzeria that can top turiellos I?ve been to... tons of different of pizzerias some of which don?t get me wrong have been good but a turiellos pie is a commodity Ive literallynothing bad to say about this place other than the fact I can?t eat it every day Read more
Great pizza with a more doughy base and very good homemade gelato. 16 inch pies sell for about $20 (plain for $16). They have a... large number of pizza options including gluten free (also sell by slice), calzones, subs, wraps, pasta, salads, appetizers anddesserts. Prices are overall decent for the portions and wait times are decent for full pies (3 pies take out took 30minutes). Their crust is more doughy and thick instead of the typical crispy, especially for the specialty pies. The plain andother regular ones were just slightly thicker than the regular New York slice. I liked the chicken Parm pie the most, althoughthe plain and margherita weren't far behind. The vanilla bean and chocolate hazelnut gelato were really good. You could seethe actual vanilla bean and hazelnuts in the respective ones and both were smooth with great flavor. Read more
I?d rate negative 1 star if I could. They are very LAZY to sum them up! Called ahead during the evening and asked what are their... dine in hours. Was informed that dine in was until 11pm(2300 for you military types). My family and I got there at 945pm andthey were very unwelcoming and accommodating. They were in the process of putting the chairs up even as we were talking to themand informing them of our dine in intentions and that we spoke with them on the phone. The family sat down and we began toarrange the tables accordingly and I was about to place another little square table at the end to accommodate our seating andfor the pizza/pasta placement. But the owner was insisting on a circle table instead saying that ?it will work the same as thecircle?. Then he denied to make a pasta dish that my girlfriend?s little sister wanted saying ? we can?t do that, it?s going totake 20 minutes to make and we?re only making the easy stuff because we?re closing?. I could understand that if it was past10pm, but still it wasn?t even 10 yet. And the stuff we ordered instead took MORE than 20 min. Then as we waited for the foodthe owner and the entire crew were staring, they were doing the same as we were eating and they began impatiently tapping theirfingers and exhaling heavily. Very rudely exhibiting their impatience with us. He was rude when me and another person from thefamily decided to split the bill. He basically acted like he didn?t know what or how to split it and didn?t even offer us anyreceipts until I asked for them. To make things worse, PAPA JOHNS is way better than this place! Ladies and Gentlemen,establishment?s such as these obviously want to get paid, yet something else is obvious about establishments like these: THEYARE NOT CUSTOMER FRIENDLY! Read more
Incredible pizza and even better staff and owners. We stopped here for a quick slice on our way back from Bear Mountain biking... on 9W. (anything tastes good after biking for 92 miles), but I could still tell this pizza was the real deal. We devoured allour slices and will definitely be back for more next bike trip. The owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming, show them somelove! Read more
Best pizza place I found so far around Nya ck (Rockland, NY).Has a delicious ice cream as well. Chattering service has really... good food, but pizza is where it really shine. Read more
OMG!!! I am not from NY so not sure how you guys rate your pizza. But this place was amazing. Loved my pizza, and the people... behind the counter. Would definitely recommend. Read more