Reviews for Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace in Old Lyme, CT
Love the Gyros platter. Best fries on the Shoreline. And my kids love the Cheesesteak. Reliably great grinders every time.
Pizza is OK but the wings are complete trash. There actually wingets for 16 bucks and you get 12. Also there Buffalo style... with no mention of that. Super expensive. 51 bucks for 12 wings, a small and large pizza. Very unhappy. Read more
Disappointed that when I called to order and wanted to pay they couldn't help because they were busy (now or later I am going to... take same amount of time) Food was very good. Feta and spinach pizza especially tasty. Previous review below reflects 2021.Always fast, good food with good value. Everyone was happy with dinner and they're always so nice! Takeout window makes it supereasy to pick up. Read more
Really quick service through their service window. Didn't appear to have their inside dining area open. That didn't affect the... speed or the quality. Really well done! Read more
Great place! Best Buffalo wings ever!!! Pizza is great! Staff is very nice! I wish we could eat in again though!
A great little sit down outside on picnic table or takeout restaurant! I almost drove right past it, but so glad we spotted it.... The woman at the window was super friendly and told us a little history of the place. The prices were reasonable and the servingsize adequate. We only got onion rings this time, which were so good ~ thick, juicy onions, surrounded by a great batter,freshly made and no long wait ~ but we'll be back for pizza next time for sure! Judging by the aroma wafting out the window, Iknow it's gonna be good! Read more
Great Greek Pizza Diner. The owner and staff here are really great folks. Easy to talk to. The meat lovers pie was chock full... of goods. The Greek style crust was spot-on. The place has a neat ambiance and is very clean. They have a lot of to gobusiness so you can assume the goods are fresh. They have draft beer and wine. Not a bad walk from the beach. Read more
Great food. Had a meatball grinder. Outside seating. Conveniently located.