Reviews for Mystic Market South in Old Saybrook, CT
We ordered a fully cooked 17lb Turkey for Thanksgiving. We picked it up Wed morning along with stuffing and gravy. It was... absolutely delicious. We were afraid that heating it up would dry it out but it was not?it was perfectly cooked and moist. Wewill definitely repeat next Thanksgiving. Read more
Stopped in for lunch. We got the Bronx bomber with brisket, pickles and other goodies. Would have liked the brisket to be the... star and not the pickles. Our antipasto was good with different types of meats and cheese. The star for me was their quinoasalad. It was hinted with curry sweet potato cubes and walnuts. I would go back for that. Read more
Try the pulled pork grilled cheese! The pesto and pickles are surprisingly good together!! They were very busy, so there might... be a little wait but everyone is super nice. They also have outside seating and are dog friendly! Read more
This place definitely has its act together. Despite people constantly coming in they were right on top of everything and the... food was excellent. My wife had fish tacos and I had A chicken sandwich. Both were excellent. Really well run place Read more
I got a california chicken sandwich to go and it was really large, which was nice. Also very warm. It was delicious, and even... though it was stuffed to the brim with sandwich fillings it didn?t fall apart. Loved it! Read more
This was a place that was 4 stars. Then this happened that I lost all respect for this place. I have many allergies and... sometimes hard to eat. Many times I have come in and gotten the same thing every time with one exception please try no onions. A dozen times they have accommodated me no problem. A woman and a man do it literally all the time no problem. Today theyrefused and said they have never done this for me. Its the only sandwich I get made into a salad. The only one I can eatcomfortably. They refused to let me have the salad/ sandwich. Not "We will try or sure no problem like usual. Just a flat outNO and lied they have NEVER done this. Was I in the twilight zone. JUST BOGGLES MY MIND. WHAT HAPPENED TO THE CUSTOMERSERVICE. I WAS A loyal customer, someone who tells people to eat here. These are when it was four stars Decided to try lunchthis time. Went over to the deli section and chose a turkey sandwich. It had roasted butternut squash, turkey,cheddar andcranberry mayo, no onions. Wow delish on sourdough bread and my boyfriend got a grinder and it was huge. The bread is crusty andjust so good. After we got a bakery treat and we both had smiles this time. Okay okay I liked that turkey butternut squashconcoction sandwich I came back again for it. Super yummy. This time I got it as a grinder. To me this place is best for thegrinders or sandwiches not their lack of fresh dessert. Okay something about this concoction with turkey and butternut squash no onions. Super yummy. Got it in a salad version minus bread. Just as delish! Read more
The store is beautiful. The presentation the frozen foods is absolutely beautiful too. The line to check out was outrageous... even though it is not even spring yet. Very short staffed probably not their fault. Our tuna wrap and Green monster sandwich wastop-quality. Read more
Very clean and warm feel in the air. The Jammin' Turkey sandwich was phenomenal. My coworker loved the Green Monster, too.... Delicious, whole ingredients that is perfect for a quick lunch. Looked like there was a lot of pre-made meals in therefrigerated section as well. There is seating inside but we took our stuff to go. Will definitely come back whenever we're inthe area. Read more