Reviews for Penny Lane Pub in Old Saybrook, CT
We have eaten here several times and always enjoy sitting outside. I had the steak and mashed with veggies. I usually plan on... eating half the meal and taking the rest home for a second meal. But, I was hungry and the food was very good so I ate it all. Read more
Really good restaurant food! Had clam chowder and ahi tuna salad. Both had great umami, good levels of seasoning and ingredients... were all fresh. Sat outdoors, lighting and heat worked well. Read more
Good food and hood service. Black Bean burger and Chilli. Fall Sangria was good .
Really really good burger, we took the classic bacon burger and the bison burger. Friendly service and we got a table in the... backyard. Read more
Great! Relaxing atmosphere, great service, excellent food and drinks.
Ate at the bar. Attending a show at the Kate. Good food. Bartender was very knowledgeable. Would go back in heartbeat!
The food was amazing and the drinks were unique and flavorful. However our waitress seemed distant and overwhelmed. She was... pleasant but all over the place. We ordered the half rack of ribs entree and Shepard's pie entree and bread pudding and 3cocktails the rib meal was $21 when we got our bill it said $31 for the ribs. We told our waitress who said well you said ribsso I put down a whole rack. We told her that he pointed to the rib meal and even showed her it was $21 and there was no optionon the menu for a whole rack. She said OK but your going to take the rest home right but you don't want to pay for the wholerack? So he put the box on the table and said you can have it back and she said let me see what i can do. Comes back and offersa solution of taking one of the cocktails off. So that was good then when she comes back with the new check it had someoneelse's credit card in it we didn't even give her our card yet. That was so scary. The issues had gotten resolved but that wasone of the worst wait staff experiences I have had. I would come back for the food but please train your staff. Thank you. Iwould give 5 Stars for food and everything else! Read more
Has the proper pub ambiance and design. Menu for the most part reflects this. Food was tasty, ribs could use a bit more of sauce... but asked and more we had, the burguer has great flavors and texture, the bread was excellent. Fish and Chips were good. Servicewas friendly. Overall we liked it. Will Go Back. Read more