Reviews for Randy's Fireside in Olean, NY
I hadn't been to Randy's Fireside in over 20 yrs. I was pleasantly surprised. I had a small fish fry and shrimp cocktail and a... salad it was all delicious and our waitress was very nice. The only reason I give them a 4 ? is because I feel the shrimp couldhave been a little bigger for jumbo shrimp cocktail and it took a little while to be served but we'll definitely go back. Read more
Good food with good portions. Pricing is very good for the amount of food received. Nice atmosphere and good service as well.
Went to Randy?s Fireside last night had to try both specials lobster ???? Mac and lobster stuffed haddock both were so... delicious!! ???? Super impressed!! Great job! Read more
First time out here. Checked in for Karaoke night. Ordered a Philly Cheesesteak with Waffle fries. Great food, nice bartenders... and nice bar! Read more
Used to love this place. Usually very good food but last night's fish fry was enough for me to think twice about returning. ... Fries excellent, 3 sides a nice touch. The fish was horrible. Tasted like they cooked it overnight. Tough, greasy and verystrange taste. If we were dining in would have returned it to the kitchen. I will return but not for the fish. Hope this isn'ta trend as the atomsphere and staff are great. Read more
Good food, good drinks and good service. Various options. Great Burgers.
Very hospitable restaurant with good food a fair prices. Full bar with several beers on tap (none sampled during this review)... and wines on selection. Furnishings cozy, including the titular fireside. Bathroom clean and waitstaff very friendly (manythanks to waitress Tirsha!). Parking unpaved directly outside, with space enough for thirty cars easy. In November 2021 theCattaraugus County Libertarian Party hosted Larry Sharpe at this location. Read more
Get place to go for a datenight. Very quant atmosphere. And delicious, filling foods. And yummy drinks.