Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Ontario, NY

My brother raves about your sub's so, I decided too pick up a couple and bring them up north to him. I ordered 2 large subs to... go. We didn't get to eat them til 7PM. Let tell you those subs were delicious. I'll definitely be getting another sub from youin the future!!!! Read more

It's Friday night and I've worked a 60 hr week.my family agreed on wings. I went in to place the order the staff was... attentive.we waited got our food went home and that's were the problem came in, the chicken was inedible it was poorly cooked(soft and fatty) the sauce was so vinegary it was gut wrenching. I tried putting it in the oven to crisp it up but to no availthe vinegar taste was to strong. So I figured i could add some lemon pepper seasoning ( i'am trying to save dinner) that stilldidn't work we attempted to salvage what we could but only could eat about another 2 piece's. So fed up I called and told themmy issues bottom line no resolution did they offer nor did they comply with the refund I was asking for. Next time I'll go tomarks which was closer anywaze Read more

This stores employee MacKenzie has posted a tiktok of this store and i saw in a comment section she said she had covid and went... to work,shopping, and school she said "what people dont know doesnt effect them" and that she said to "cry about it" and to"stay mad" i think that is awful behavior online she said she went to work with covid and definitely wouldnt trust an employeelike that Read more

Congratulations, this may be the worst Salvatores out of the entire franchise. Food quality is always terrible & ran by people... who don't seem to care. I'd suggest going to either Webster or Walworth locations Read more

It's hit or miss lunch hour rather they have slices or not. I've had days I've waited 20 min in line to get a slice and they... completely out of them and I've had days where it's a ghost town and it's in and out. But the pizza has always been good! Read more

Worst pizza in Rochester. Every single time it is greasy and floppy... I don't understand how a single person enjoys the pizza... here... A few other items are standard run of the mill items... but pizza.... It's worse than Jacks pizza, and that's sayingsomething. Here is a picture of their "Thin Thin European style pizza." Would give 0 stars if I could. Read more

Just picked up a slice to go. The slices are MASSIVE. but, they'll cut them I half for you :) I also thought the pizza was... really good (I just had cheese). Would definitely est pizza here again. They do have combo options to add drinks and snacks.They also have a pretty large menu of things other than pizza. Read more

I decided to give this particular Salvatore's pizza three stars because the staff was very friendly and the restaurant was very... clean; for a pizza place. My son absolutely loves pizza and is somewhat of a pizza connoisseur. I decided to take him herebecause I use to love the way that the pizza was prepared at their Dewey Ave. location in Rochester, New York. Well, my sonand I did not enjoy the pizza because it was too greasy. They put too much pepperoni on the pizza and that plus the oil fromthe cheese made it too much grease. They put so many pepperonies on the pizza that there was hardly any empty cheese spaces. Weall bought chicken wings. They were okay but nothing special. The best thing about the wings was the Boss sauce that was placedon them. The children wings were cooked a little too long making them a little too hard. I also thought that the food was overpriced. A large pizza came up to $18.00 plus change. I add 10 chicken wings and my order was almost $35.00. I thought the pricewas extremely high considering I bought the pizza on a Wednesday night. Read more