Reviews for NYC Meatballs & Pizzeria in Orange Park, FL

Food and service was great. Will definitely be back if I'm in the area.

Nice ad welcoming atmosphere. Kinda family sports bar feel. My Husband ordered a Meat Lover's pizza and mild wings. We LOVED the... pizza. Wings taste like bar wings. I had the lasagna ad must say it did not disappoint. Portion size hug and taste to match. Read more

Been couple times now. Great food and service! Young man behind the bar (sadly forgot his name) does fabulous job taking care of... you. All the food has been great. One of the top pizzas have had in long time! Thank guys! Read more

Revisited the chicken parmigiana plate with pasta. Tasty sauce, nice size portion of pasta with 2 strips of chicken, which was... also tasty. Left wanting more. ?? Read more

Everytime I've visited, the food and service were on point. Pizzas are delicious; haven't had a bad one yet! Garlic knots are... really good, too. My recent visit I tried the lasagna. Great choice. Huge portion, cheesy, flavorful and came with two garlicbread slices. It's hard to find good lasagna without having to visit an expensive Italian restaurant. I'll definitely return forthe lasagna and, of course, the pizza. Thursdays are discounted beers, too! Read more

What changed?! We used to love ordering from here. We had a pizza and garlic Parmesan wings. The pizza was BURNT SO BADLY. The... wings were shriveled and dry. I called back to say the pizza was burnt and never received the marinara sauce I ordered. Noapologies, I felt like a burden, but they sent a new pizza. Still no marinara sauce the second time. When opening the pizza Iasked my husband if he ordered a thin crust? the quality has changed drastically. We won?t be ordering again. This is not thesame food we used to love so much. Read more

Ordered pepperoni pizza with wings - Received incorrect order, called the shop to correct the issue. Took over an hour to... receive the "corrected" order. After picking out the extra toppings, because I figured if I called to correct the issue again, imight end up with Chinese food, I found the pizza slightly better than the chain pizza places, but not by much. The mini wingssealed the deal, will not be a repeat customer. Read more

Born and raised in NYC, this place doesn't even begin to touch any of Tri-state area pizza. This experience was horrible. The... crust on the pizza and garlic knots were the only positive things. I will never order from here again. I actually threw thepizza away tonight, no one enjoyed this pizza. Read more