Reviews for Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Orem, UT
Lucy?s is delicious! I have never been disappointed when I eat here. The pizza is huge, the New York style slice size and crust... width is well within New York limits. My wife loves the margarita pizza and I could go for just about anything there. I stoppedby on Wednesday for a quick bite and got a calzone. The thing was huge and only cost $7 with two types of cheese and onetopping. Of course I added more to it, but it was totally worth it. I usually stop in there between 1 and 3. It?s not too busyaround that time so you get excellent service relatively quickly. I do wish they would bring back the breakfast pizza. That wasprobably my favorite. Looking for a great place to grab a slice? This is your place! Read more
Service was slow. You have to cut your own pizza, grab your own utensils, grab your own plate, and clean up after yourself and... others. They ask for a tip to make your pizza that's it, no customer service. With four people working, not much service wasgoing on. The place was dirty, I didn't see anyone cleaning or clearing tables. Pizza was okay definitely not Real New Yorkstyle pizza, had way better. Read more
I love Lucy(?s) - my family and I have been coming here for years and it?s always been incredible! However, I haven?t been in... about a year. A few things have changed?. No wait to be seated (no big deal) no olives and oil with order (kind of bummed) butno plates and silverware with the food is a little lazy. They do have a spot with paper plates and napkins. All of theaforementioned things are not a huge deal and I?m being picky, but the issue I did have is ordering a beer and it coming outhalf full of foam and after letting it settle it was a legit half beer. I understand not knowing how to pour beer let alone fromthe tap so it?s understandable. I did. Ask for the beer to be topped off and it was just replaced with a new beer that wasalmost full. So thank you for a beer and a half and for the amazing food! Maybe get a little training on pouring beer and maybego back to how you used to be ! But I will still support you and eat your pizza. 5 stars still even with my rant. Cheers Read more
Finally found a place that taste like pizza from back home (NJ). The cheese and crust are so good, I just wish the pizza was a... little firmer instead of flimsy towards the front. This place is definitely ?NY Style? APPROVED. The wings were pretty good too.I?ll be back. Read more
This pizza was delicious! Thin crust that was tasty and excellent sauce. They offer a lunch special, however ; we ordered a... whole pie for leftovers. Our server suggested we try the Firesticks, those are awesome if you like a little spice in your life!They also had really good Ranch for a dipping sauce. Our server was great, the pizza was wood fired and excellent. I suggest youcheck it out for yourself! Read more
Great little pizzeria. During the dinner rush, the wait to get our food was a bit longer than we would have liked. However,... service was incredibly kind, pizza was classically tasty, and restaurant was clean. Great prices too, especially if you have thelocal starving student card coupons. Read more
Friendly staff, clean restaurant. Ordered 2 slices, got a whole pie which was nice of them to do. Pizza is of true NY fashion... (big, thin, cheesy, slice). As Dave Portnoy would say "good undercarriage", good crisp, good flavor. I'd give it a 7.9, which ispretty good for not being on the east coast. Overall great experience, great pizza!???? Read more
This place was amazing and authentic, for Utah, to be called NY style a year ago. It was our go to for great pizza. Now, it has... become forgetable. We loved the marinated olives. Ordered some a month ago and they were not the same, nasty lackluster flavor.The pizza was also a bland miss which I assumed we just didn't order the right one and was forgiving. Ordered a margarita lastnight with cheese stick, neither impressed. Cheese stick was waxy bland cheese over flavorless bread. The pizza? An insult toItalians, New York and couldn't be called a margarita. IMO the greatness of this pizza is the simplicity but burst of flavor.This was a filled of just to fill your stomach. Too much cheap waxy cheese with no flavor. The sauce was red but that's all thatresembled sauce. The tomatoes were not ripe, and its' summer tomato season! (which there are ways to manipulate the fruit topull flavor out) They were colorless, flavorless and were hard....yes hard. Then I asked for some additional pepper, because Ineeded something with a flavor, and they charged for plastic condiment cup. I get things cost money, but really? I should havetraded the bad cheese bread in exchange for the peppers because I just wanted some flavor somewhere. I hope, I really hope thatthese guys can turn the corner and get back to what they were over a year ago when you they were worth the dive and money spent.two strikes, I don't think I can stomach a third chance. Come on guys, do be just another pizza filler, be the amazing you oncewere. Read more