Reviews for Brother Jimmy's BBQ in Orlando, FL

The food was great as we had a group of nine and everyone enjoyed their meals. The Fried Pickles, Buffalo Shrimp and Nachos were... great appetizers. We had Brisket, Pork, Chicken and Salads as entrees and all were excellent as was the Mac and Cheese as aside. The Banana Pudding as a desert was also great. Carisa the owner, Ben the Chef and David the Bartender were all veryfriendly and efficient. We will all be back. It’s a welcome addition to the I Drive area. Read more

Wow, what a place. Food was delicious, atmosphere was fantastic and staff were incredible and super friendly, we even had a... lovely chat with the manager who was great. BBQ was great, ribs & pulled pork done well, the mac & cheese and loaded fries wereawesome too. 100% recommend this place for amazing food and service! Read more

Had dinner there about 7 PM on a Saturday. Our waitress Bella was great! Very helpful, checked back often and kept us updated on... when our food would be ready. The kitchen made a mistake with one item in our order and Bella came to us, let us know whathappened and gave us options on how they could fix it. We opted to have the item remade and they did that for us. When the foodcame out of the kitchen, some items were missing, and we had to ask about them. Bella was able to get them for us, but it tookextra time. The food was good, but the cost/ value was a bit high to me. Even with 10% off entire check for the mistake, I’mnot sure it was a good value for what we got. The brisket was very tasty, and the chicken sandwich was good. The Mac and cheesewas very very heavy and missed the mark. YMMV. I think I would come back for drinks, games, and maybe an app or two, butprobably not for full meals unless the prices come down a bit. Great staff, fun atmosphere, cold drinks, so/so food. Read more

Delicious food and excellent service. I highly recommend the three combo plate with the brisket, brisket, and brisket. You will... not regret it. The loaded fries and nachos are also so tasty! Seriously, just get here and eat well! Read more

This place is not "amazing". Pulled into Orlando late and were looking for a BBQ spot that was still open Found Brother Jimmy's.... 9:00 on a Friday night and it was dead. I other table was occupied. Food was okay. Portions are small. We ordered my son acheeseburger from the kids menu and it was a burger on a dinner roll (literally 2.5 inches wide). my wife had a chicken sandwichand a marguerita, while I had a quarter chicken, pulled pork and a beer. Entrees come with one side and a piece of cornbread.Not a lot of food for $100. Read more

Great experience we will definitely return. Sarah and the rest of the staff was friendly and inviting. Food was good definitely... try the brussel sprouts could have made a meal with just those alone. The ribs definitely had a bark on them that was not mypersonal preference of toughness but some people prefer it that way. They mac and cheese entire is big enough to share betweentwo hungry adults for sure. My only suggestion is rotate one of the draft taps for more of a craft selection. Read more

Five star food, five star service. Absolutely incredible experience we were so well looked after by Bella and Jorge. Hands down... best BBQ and most attentive service we’ve ever had in our lives and will probably come back again before we leave. Decor isunique and full of character, what an amazing place. Read more

Wow wow wow amazing BBQ right in Icon Park next to the valet area! This place is amazing with large portions, great drinks and... the staff are amazing Jorge and Mike are amazing and the atmosphere is right for the area. Cool games to play with a nice areafor your large parties! BBQ wow when you see a bbq joint it better be good and this place knocks it out of the park literally!Fantastic we will be back for sure! Read more