Reviews for Celestino's New York Pizza in Oroville, CA
Our family LOVES Celestino?s! The food is fabulous and delicious. We usually get the Hawaiian style, Tom Jones, Olive special,... mushroom or just plain cheese with the Kid Cut. They cut up the giant slices into smaller pieces so it?s easier to eat. Thestaff is friendly and attentive, even when they are busy. We love the fact that many of the slices we like are sitting there,basically ready to go. You don?t have to wait for a whole pizza. You can order online and getting a whole pizza is even fasterif that?s what you?re looking for. They also have beautiful salads and giant portions of specialty fries. I always recommendCelestino?s for a quick place to eat. Read more
Salad here is way better than The Patio. If you want your pizza crust less crunchy, just request it.
Fresh pizza and salad. Great customer service. I forgot one of my order and the staff came running to my car to hand over the... salad I left on the checkout counter. Read more
I ordered from door dash and this place made it horrible! We got an XL Hawaiian with added bacon. Pizza was extremely greasy and... very cheap on toppings. I counted 10 total pieces of Canadian bacon , maybe 2 table spoons of pineapple and less then a tablespoon of the crispy bacon that they charged us $5.50 for, and again this was on an XL pizza. I also ordered the appetizer combo.The fried pickles were cooked in one big glob so that only the edges were cooked and when you tried to pull them apart they werejust raw gooey dough, just nasty. Even the couple of pickles that were actually separated and cooked were so greasy and youcould taste how old the oil was. The mozzarella sticks and fried ravioli were also extremely under cooked but that's ok becausethey didn't bother to give me the marinara sauce so to me those would've been inedible anyways. I called and spoke to managerthinking I could just send my boyfriend over to pick up replacement for the appetizer combo and manager was rude and said therewas nothing he could do about it!!! Nasty food, BAD Management!! Read more
Always loved celestino?s pizza 5 stars for the last decade but as of 2022 every single pizza I?ve ordered is dry as a bone.... Pizza is supposed to come with sauce not dry dough and cheese. I can get that for 5.00 not 50.00. I hope they get back on trackotherwise my fav pizza joint for the last 24 years will rank lower that little Caesar?s Read more
Went there for my grandaughters birthday. Unfortunately the pizza was very oily and one was burnt. The pizza could have been... better for the price. And it took a long time to be served. We have had better pizza there in the past. Update 6/30/22 it wasok. Read more
Delicious food! Amazing service
Pizza was really good. Pretty over-priced if you build your own, but inflation I guess. Staff was super friendly. I did take out... thankfully because the vibe inside was a bit like chuck-e-cheese as far as the clientele was concerned. Maybe it's not alwayslike that but if you aren't into eating where the children outnumber the adults I wouldn't plan on dining in at thisestablishment. Read more