Reviews for Lincoln Way Pizza in Orrville, OH
Never seems like they are open to order food for me and my family.
First time customer. Ordered 1 Lg supreme & 1 Lg 3 item pizzas. Only thing noteworthy is the extra cheese they put on their... pizzas. Crust was a little over baked, vegetables are chopped too fine & pepperoni are small, light on the bland sauce. Pizzasare a little smaller than industry standards. Probably all due to saving money. Not worth $33. Read more
I only share one star because zero stars is not an option. This restaurant accepted a grub hub order...waited for hour and... half...canceled the order with no phone call, nothing. IF YOU CANT FULFILL THE REQUESTED ORDER, DONT WAIT OVER AN HOUR TOCANCEL AND THEN CLOSE. BTW....YOU SHOULD ALSO ANSWER YOUR PHONE WHEN YOU SAY YOU ARE OPEN. Read more
Ordered Lincoln Way pizza for the first time and it did not disappoint. Got a medium with pepperoni, mushroom, onion and extra... cheese. Probably could?ve done without the extra cheese because there was indeed a TON of cheese but that?s OK life?s betterwith cheese. I will definitely be back! Read more
I Order from here often and This is the best pizza place in Orrville. The food is always fresh and fantastic. Service is great... and cost is much more reasonable than most places. You won't be disappointed Read more
Awesome phone service and delivery was prompt. Driver friendly polite and well dressed. Food was amazing large portions. The... side salad itself could of made a meal. Hillbilly hotdog excellent got 3 different kinds of subs and they were all amazing. Allcosting under $30 and defiantly getting a couple meals here. Will eat there again. Read more
I normally love this place. Only one other company around has a taco pizza and they want more than it's worth. They usually have... fantastic chicken and Jos. However, the last couple times I've ordered, just the last couple weeks, I've been disappointed. Iordered a taco pizza and buffalo pizza one night, the buffalo pizza was really good, but the taco pizza was not. The pizzastarted as a taco pizza, but ended as just a regular pizza. Maybe a new employee learning the ropes, no big deal. Then my momhad me over for dinner and she ordered chicken and Jos. Chicken was chewy and over cooked. Jos were fine, but it's hard to messfried potatoes up. Really hoping I get to improve this review, as I've enjoyed this place for years. Would recommend to otherswhen they are operating on their "A" game. Read more
Possibly new owners or at least new employees. They definitely have a new menu. Food was good