Reviews for Old Carolina Barbecue Company - Orrville in Orrville, OH

Just a fantastic restaurant with great people and even better service. I loved the food and would absolutely recommend eating... here. Great work Old Carolina Team! Read more

Amazing place to eat and great for the community. Thank you so much Tanner Bruder and Diane Jarrett for letting cubscouts sell... popcorn. Also thank you to Dustin Miller for being a great help and thanks to the rest of the staff. Quinton Hewitt, KendraTaylor, Jacob Griffin, and Karen Binkered are amazing people to accommodate the pack. I know my family loves to eat here andwill always come back. Read more

The staff was very friendly and helpful. Food is good. Huge thank you to Tanner Bruder for allowing our local Cub Scout group... to come and do our popcorn fundraiser. The staff was very helpful and supportive. Especially Dustin Miller who checked with usa few times. While there many in our group ordered food. FYI unsure if Nate mentioned it to you, the restaurant has anincentive program to reward employees mentioned in good reviews. The other employees there who helped us were awesome as well,thanks to Quinton Hewitt Kendra Taylor Jacob Griffin Karen Binkerd A great restaurant supporting our community! Read more

Went with the chicken platter, I figured it would be a bigger portion than the $7 sandwich. WRONG! $10.50 for a very very small... portion of chicken. It was good but come on! Mac & cheese was half warm & half cold, it sucked! My sons chicken finger platterhad 3 huge pieces of chicken and a ton of fries. Read more

The wings are great, meat tastes awesome. However, the new cornbread muffins and cinnamon butter are not worth getting at all... any more - the muffins are always dry and bland, and the ?butter? separates into an oily mess. Read more

The place was awesome from the smell as we walked in the door to the customer service we got and I can?t forget the food me and... my wife will definitely be returning the servings we got were more then filling and super delicious and my daughter is a superpicky eater and even she loved it. Read more

We had a great experience. The staff were all very friendly and helpful. The food arrived quickly, and was delicious. We'll... definitely be back. I especially enjoyed the baked beans. That was favorite side dish. Read more

Never been here before, but was vary happy with my food. We were in the area for a weekend visit and managed to squeeze in lunch... here before we left. The sweet tea was spot on. Not to sweet, not to unsweeten. I had the pulled pork and opted for the slicedbrisket as opposed to the chopped. I have smoked meats for many years and its a lot easier to hide so so food when its chopped.The brisket was moist and tender, and the smoke ring was very evident. It stood firmly on its own and didn't need any sauce tomake it better. The pork was tender and flavorful and the sauces just accentuated that. The fries and beans were about as goodas I've had anywhere. While I'm giving it 5 stars, it's more like 4.75 because no one is perfect. I look forward to stoppingagain. Read more