Reviews for Insomnia Cookies in Oshkosh, WI
Recent experience VS experiences from 1+ years ago. Recent... Prices higher and cookie quality taste texture down. Not sure if... new recipes or owners either way the cookies just taste like average decent cookies (yes I got them warm) In the past theyweren't as expensive and I can live with the price increase but not at the expense of cheaper quality. The peanut butter cookieswere my favorite In the past they were melty, toasty, roasty, peanuts in them, drizzle of peanut butter on top. Now they arejust basic somewhat peanut butter flavored sugar cookie style. I made better ones at home the other night with 5 or lessingredients. Sad to see the negative changes and I think I won't be going back again. Read more
If super sweet cookies are the stuff your dreams are made of, then this is the place for you. We got a cookie sandwich (salted... caramel and confetti cookies with buttercream) and an ice cream sandwich. Both sandwiches had warm gooey cookies and sweetcenters. I personally prefer the buttercream, but that's because I love my treats super sweet. The chocolate chunks were big,the staff was pleasant. Five stars all around. I definitely would have been a frequent visitor if we had this on my campusduring college. Read more
my 7 new friends and i took a little journey here last night and were treated to polite, friendly staff and?you guessed it?the... best cookies i've had . . . EVER! also, i like the drink coolers. you have two choices: milks and not milks. :) Read more
Really yummy cookies and ice cream to go with. I appreciate that they stay open until 1AM.
I got 6 cookies for $32.00 with shipping !! They weren?t worth that much !! Honestly ? Quik Trip chocolate chip cookies are way... better and you get a dozen for $5 !!!! Never will I pay that much for just ok cookies ever again Read more
Maybe it's the location but, it wasn't all I expected. The online ordering didn't update as advertised. My order was sitting on... top of a oven and wasn't close to warm. So I guess it was done a couple hours before my scheduled pick up. I was shorted acookie on the order and charged extra for "wrapping". Cookies had decent taste even if there just sugar cookies with flavors.Small store, little seating but, the 1 worker was friendly and helpful. Not the worst place but nothing to go out of your wayfor. Be great if your right there otherwise I'd skip Read more
these cookies are the bomb! Delivered warm and not too sweet. I am hooked. White macadamia nut, peanut butter, sugar, chocolate... mint, oatmeal raisin x2 Read more
I love insomnia. Almost always get fresh cookies, definitely addictive, so watch out lol. The few times I've had older cookies... weren't great, but that's not too usual. Highly recommend these. Read more