Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Oshkosh, WI
I've added customer appreciation date to my calendar which is the first tuesday of every month. My go to is the chicken bacon... ranch. I like it way more than Little Caesars and on that day its about the same price. The staff is friendly and I like thatyou can watch them make everything right in front of you. Yes they do toss the dough in the air! They are very efficient andthe average wait is usually 15 mins or less after you put in the order (depending on what you get). Read more
Beware when ordering a delivery. Wife ordered a pizza. Never got it ,BUT GOT CHARGED. Called several times. "Driver said it was... hand delivered to you" Used to go here a lot. NEVER AGAIN. Read more
Great pizza and wings always made just right and get them hot when either getting carryout or have them delivered
Awful. Online tracking definitely not accurate. Food was room temperature apon arival.On top of that, a plastic container with... my chicken wings in it was popped open, with a wing on my wooden steps, as I ordered contanctless delivery. Will certainly NEVERorder from again. Read more
Young guys working there were friendly and courteous. Pizza was average. We had ordered the Hawaiian style. I DID order on... their special customer appreciation day, so large pizza was only about $7. 1st Tuesday of every month they offer this for anylarge 2 topping pizza, so it WAS a great value. Must have code to get the deal. Read more
Always have the best experience!! Pizza is ALWAYS HOT and FAST delivery FROM THE STORE THEMSELVES!!! Beats ordering from... eatstreet/doordash, etc. because if you order from the app, again such as eatstreet/doorsash there are a lot of times there areeither not enough drivers or they will turn up late and the food is COLD!! I will always tip them $10+!! Price is very pricey,but if you want GREAT quality, it's WORTH the price! DO NOT order from eatstreet/doordash!! ALWAYS call the store!!! Read more
They were the best of times and the worst of times. As I entered the pizza order into the app, I selected the NY Style deal with... one NY Style and one Stuffed Crust. I was hesitant at first, but apart from the slight anxiety I felt for using the deal, Ipushed through and hit order. Whew, a relief swept over me in my decision to order. When the pop up arrived in my app statingthat I could monitor the progress of my food being created from the freshest ingredient by the most competent pizza artisans, Iwas excited. As the pure anticipation pulled me in all directions of emotion, I kept it together. I saw my food was ready so Iproudly told my wife, ?I?m going to go grab the pizza.? She replied with a resounding, ?Whatever.? Out the door I went. As Ipulled up in front of the store with the anticipation of a puppy with a treat on its nose, I took a deep breath and headedinside. I was greeted by two smiling faces, they handed me my order. I smiled and thanked them for their knowledge andgenerosity. I left, feeling an odd mixture of senses, mostly sadness as with the turnover rate in employment, I may never seethese two artisans again. Ah well. I took the pizza home and ate it. Amazing day. Read more
For being the first time getting pizza from Papa John's, I am not at all disappointed. A whole pepperoni, half chicken, half... extra sausage, extra large New York Style pizza is just what I need for watching Batman vs Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Thesausage and pepperoni side is a taste of the familiar, while the chicken and pepperoni side is a step into the unknown andunbelievably delicious. I have a feeling this is going to be my standard order from now on whenever I order from Papa John's. Read more