Reviews for Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay in Oyster Bay, NY

We come here at least twice a month and the pizza is always fresh and made to order. A pie only comes in one size that easily... feeds two. Call ahead on a Friday-Saturday evening, they get slammed for orders and delivery may take a little longer. Read more

This is the best pizzeria on long island. The selection of assorted slices is so good. I especially love the broccoli rabe... slice. Incredible! Very decent Sicilian as well as chicken slices. There are other Mario's, but this one is the best. Alwaysstop by when I am in the area. Read more

This place was really, really, good. Try a side of meatballs with what ever you eat. Trust me. That's a pic of the meatball... after the fact. Sorry couldn't control myself. Read more

The best gluten free pizza I've had so far. ????

A small family owned chain throughout Long Island. Very nice menu . A little on the pricey side. I ordered the Cold Italian... Special Hero, different meats and provolone cheese with lettuce and tomato, just fair. My wife tried the Eggplant ParmigianaHero, which she enjoyed. We have had pizza previously which was very good. Read more

Great place, super nice people, and pizza is delicious, this whole pie felt like it weighed 20lbs. Penne Alla vodka pizza.... ???????????????????????????????? One of the BEST pizzas wifey and I have ever eaten. Read more

Great service, Great pizza, I have been going here since 1969 when it first opened. I highly recommend the Spinach slice this... pizza is the best period it?s run very professionally and there is always a table no matter how crowded you will not bedissatisfied with Mario?s Pizza. Mario?s Turned Fifty at this time buy one pizza get one free. Read more

A grand Pizzeria experience with lots of options you won't fine anyplace else. A good normal, a bit sweet, and some well... balanced specialty slices. Works fast and works well, with nice comfortable digs, and great big booths for dining. Love it. Read more