Reviews for Pauly's NY Pizza & Ice Cream in Parkville, MD
I saw this restaurant a few weeks ago while driving by and decided to go for lunch today. First off Pauly's has a cool decor... ,reminds me of a 50's diner. I came in around noon and was immediately welcomed by a very nice young lady. Pauly's has anextensive menu but on this day I was feeling a meatball parm sandwich and fries. I grabbed a booth, not very long after I wasdelivered a great looking platter. Sandwich was perfectly buttered toasted ( not just heated bread) 6 large meatballs, sauce anda lot of cheese. I've had a lot of meatball parm sandwiches in New York, Philly but this was the best by far. You could see thevarious Italian seasoning that gave it such good flavor. Sandwich was very large enough for two but I managed to eat it allbecause it was that good. The boardwalk fries were perfectly seasoned and also very good. Pauly's is a great find and I can'twait to sample other dishes. I highly recommend. Read more
This was our first time ordering here. We got 3 Meatball subs and the Jersey fries. Everything was absolutely delicious! Biggest... meatballs I've ever had on a perfectly toasted sub roll. They were juicy and hot and the sauce was very good as well. Also thesubs can feed 2 people. The fries were very unique in taste and the seasoning they used on the fries was excellent. I lookforward to ordering other foods there, and I hope Pauly's becomes our new place to get subs, etc. 10/10 Read more
The food here is delicious and fresh. First timer and they did not disappoint. The staff was great and friendly. Pizza... delicious, cheesesteak subs delicious, fries with cheese and gravy delicious. Not skimpy on the portions either. My family andI could not eat all of our food and had plenty of leftovers. Oh and we did desserts of cookie dough, ice cream sandwiches andbanana pudding which were all great too. We will be back!!! Read more
Stopped by for my first time and was not disappointed. Ordered a large Pepperoni Pie and a Chocolate Mousse, the Pepperoni was... super crispy and the Mousse was super soft and delicious. Staff was friendly and the establishment is kept very clean. The menuhas alot of options so I will definitely be coming back to try more! Read more
First time here, met up with family for lunch. The staff at Pauly's is absolutely the BEST, a person in our party was... celebrating his birthday, the staff apparently over heard our conversation and went way beyond what they had to, and surprisedus all.. Absolutely thankful for the gesture. Also, the food is fantastic, the pickle pizza was crazy. We will definitely beback. Thank you all again. Read more
We had the vegan life pizza and it was amazing! The fries were also delicious. Staff was super nice and restaurant was clean. We... can?t wait to go back. Read more
Tried this place for the first time and have to say that it is a must stop for all you foodies. Vodka chicken pizza was... extremely cheesy which I love. The cheeseburger tacos where by far my favorite and my wife loved the cheessteak tacos. Herfavorite was the fries with gravy that had such a great flavor. We will definitely be back to try some other things as well.Please give this place a try and support a local place. Ps. Get a milkshake ???????? Read more
I am very disappointed I stopped in with hopes of a very good pizza and I was let down the prices were outrageous 53$ for a... pizza, garlic bread, mozzarella sticks,and a drink. When at some other pizza restaurants you can get way better pizza and allthis for around 30$. I would of been fine if the prices were expensive and the pizza was at least above average but for belowaverage pizza these prices are just outrageous.And I know that the Baltimore area has decent pizza but this pizza barely evenhas cheese I did not pay 53 dollars for a pizza with barely any cheese.However I did not give this place a 1 star rating becausethe staff was kind along with the fact that a strong robust sauce might be satisfying for some people. Read more