Reviews for Pearl River Pizzeria in Pearl River, NY
the square Sicilian pie we got from this place is the best we\'ve had anywhere in this state. It was a very relaxed hemisphere... and the staff was warm and friendly. Read more
The gluten free pizza here might have been one of the worst I have had. The dough tasted like saltine crackers and they barely... put any toppings on. The price was ridiculous, for two small gluten free pizzas it came out to $50. No pizza as bad as thisshould cost that much. Read more
Finally got a chance to check out the new place up the block, and it didn\'t disappoint. We ordered a large cheese pie... (toppings are expensive at $5 each!) that was more thin crust than traditional. As a thin crust enthusiast I welcomed this, andit\'s a nice change of pace from local pizza. I also ordered a sicilian slice that was good and quite thick. The cheese wasgood, and small crust was tasty. The sauce could have been stronger, which is why I\'m not giving five stars. Overall the pizzawas good and having different types of options is always a good thing!\n\nA menu caveat: I wanted to check out a cauliflowerpie, but at $17 for a 10\" it\'s never happening. Most places are $12 or $13. Read more
Ate here with my family last night, the place looks amazing and the food was absolutely delicious. The inside was very clean,... service was fast and friendly. Best Grandma pie I’ve ever had, would definitely recommend this place to anyone in the area. Read more
worst pizza slices i have ever gotten.\nBurnt, dry, hard as a rock and taste like cardboard.\nWent straight into the trash where... it belongs.\nIf this is how you like your pizza this is your goto place otherwise you should look elsewhere. Read more
Delicious!! We ordered a cheese pie as well as a half meatball half sausage pie and they both were delicious! The sauce alone... makes me want to try everything they make. Highly recommend!!\n\nJust had the sauteed spinach roll.OMG!! Just like homemadewith sauteed garlic. My father would have loved this place.\nYummy!! Can\'t wait to try something else!! Read more
Welcome to the neighborhood. We ordered the Grandma pie it was one of the best we ever had. The garlic knots are so soft and... doughy.\nGood luck. Can’t wait to try other items. Read more
Love that Grandma\'s Pizza! Really nice folks. I hope they\'re really successful in the space! Definitely give it a try if... you\'re in town. Read more