Reviews for Macelleria Italian Steakhouse Pelham in Village of Pelham, NY

Great restaurant, friendly and helpful staff. The food tasted great. Well worth a visit if you happen to be in Pelham.

Cozy and warm dining experience for a family baptism. Unparalleled service and food quality I will absolutely be back. The food... here is truly tasty. Read more

It’s a second time we visit this restaurant and both times it was delicious and simply amazing. First time we were invited for... a birthday party and were able to try nearly all items in the menu. Everything was simply outstanding, my personal favouriteswere octopus, clams and ricotta from appetisers and truffle risotto. Steaks are very good as well. I would say that the pricingis very reasonable for the food of such quality. I love outside dining options in summer time… Read more

Always a big fan of La Fontanella across the street we decided to try something new and come here. We were immediately... disappointed. My dirty martini was made with lime juice (really??!??). I sent it back and asked for a vodka on the rocks(can’t mess that up) Our salads were good. Four our five dinners were very good. One of the dishes (the salmon andbroccoli rabe) was tasteless. Both the Fish and the broccoli rabe. Fast forward to dessert. The key lime pie had no hint oflime. The tiramisu was very good. I probably won’t come back or recommend this place to anyone. Read more

My update a year later it’s still gooood. I hold EVERYTHING I do to a very high standard. SoOO many awesome things I can say... about this place which is RARE. If you don’t know what love is. Start here. Read more

The ambiance was lovely. The staff was very attentive and provided excellent customer care. They went above and beyond. The... owner came out and wished us a happy anniversary, he was very friendly and we will definitely be back! Oh and the apple martiniswere sooooo good! Read more

Jesus Christ!! The food is just amazing, the wine selection is outstanding, the service is over the top. I haven't felt this... welcomed in a restaurant in a long time. I can't wait to return. Read more

I can’t believe I never heard of this place before. I ordered my food ahead of time and was ready upon arrival. Everyone was... so nice it was hard to believe. Due to covid 19 indoor eating is not available but delivery and to go is fully operational. Thefood was delicious I’ve already made plans to return. I ordered ribeye steak, creamy spinach , salmon, rabe, chickenmargarita, salad, burger and whipped potato. Read more