Reviews for Geraci's Restaurant University Hts in Pepper Pike, OH

The food is good- the restaurant itself absolutely disgusting. Have they ever cleaned their bathrooms? The smell of cleaner is... so strong it burns your throat, and you smell it as soon as you enter. Food may be good, service subpar, but the filth is reallywhat is making me not return here. Read more

I would have thought the pasta would’ve came with garlic bread but it was plain white. But what really got me was this... extremely small portion of pasta. For $24 for a dinner I expect a dinner portion of pasta not a lunch size. I have eaten at thisrestaurant plenty of times and don’t recall ever having such a small portion of pasta. We only received on dressing for ourside salad and the cups were only half full. Just overall dissatisfied Read more

The location is good and the restaurant nice enough, but somehow the great pizza I used to get at their original restaurant is... not just OK. Whether eating in or ordering out, the crust is OK, the sauce ok, and the ability to keep your order straight, justok. I liked the ingredients on the meat lovers, but the crust was soggy. The deluxe wasn't bad, but the four shreds of greenpepper hardly qualify as a topping. That's a garnish. Finally, last time we ordered a white pizza with toppings, we got standardred sauce. OK, but it didn't go with the toppings we ordered, so disappointing. Hope they can get motivated again. Read more

Service was TERRIBLE. They forgot about us. It wasn't until they seated other people that they realized we hadn't been waited... on. The server didn't come check on us at all after taking our order. I wouldn't be so mad and disappointed if it was busy butit was not busy at all. Aside from us there were only 3 other tables with people. The food tasted good but they got my orderwrong. I thought the pasta dinner came with bread and a salad but ours didn't. Maybe it didn't but the menu said it did. Againthe waitress did not come at all to check on us so I couldn't ask her. We had to flag down one of the food servers to get usboxes and our checks. Overall great food but horrible service. Would not recommend and would not visit again. Read more

Pretty good pizzas! In will have to update my review when we dine in. We were trying to order from Pie-O-Mine but that place is... so unreliable when it comes to staff. Anyway, we needed pizzas so went to Geraci’s. Pizza was fresh and delicious. The staffwere attentive and very helpful. The restaurant looks family owned and had a very friendly and homey atmosphere. It was day andnight compared to Pie-O-mine. My husband and I want to come back to try their other dishes and to dine in. Excited to try diningin next time! Food was good enough for us to want to come back. Read more

We had a fantastic experience at Geraci's Restaurant! Our server was wonderful and the food was superb! I highly recommend the... lasagna, it was the best I have ever tasted! My husband ordered penne with meat sauce and he also really enjoyed it! Must try ifyou're in the Pepper Pike area! Read more

Family-owned Italian Fantastic Pasta, Pizza, and specialty Italian dishes Family friendly kids menu - full bar with beer, wine... and cocktails. Super friendly staff Read more

Absolutely phenomenal food and service from an amazing local family. EVERYTHING is made from scratch. Pasta's and traditional... dishes are amazing but I go for the PIZZA!! Best in Cleveland and an honor to enjoy. Can't say enough great things about thisplace - go and eat here immediately!! Read more