Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza Delivery & Takeout in Petaluma, CA

Always a great pizza like none other in this area. You won't be disappointed.

The double crust pizza is hands down my all time favorite pizza. There's nothing like it anywhere!

Great deep dish pizza. I love the crust and I really love the dough. The double crust is extreme, and a little to much for... me, but the deep dish is perfect. Also, amazing customer service. I can order, give them a pick up time, and it's always readywhen I show up. Super friendly team that works there. There are a lot of great pizza places in Petaluma, but this one is thebest pie. Dont forget to stop by Angelas Ice Cream shop which is next door and pick up a pint to go. Perfect pairing! Read more

The pizza was super watery also not even cut.also the sauce was tasteless I honestly like little Cesars more than that pizza.did... not even finish the pizza and usually I will just cause I bought it you know but it was not for it will not go back agian.Hopefully they have some better cooks in there to work some magic. Good luck to anyone getting that pizza from there hopefullyyours is better than mine. Read more

My favorite pizza place. Deep dish pepperoni and sausage is the best. Call in your pickup order ahead as it takes at least 45... mins to cook. Ranch is a little pricey at $1 for a small cup. Read more

Seriously delicious pizza that the whole family enjoyed! We got a deep dish combo, thin crust pepperoni & deep dish cheese.... Simply amazing! Read more

Been a loyal customer for nearly 40 years, since the beginning. Literally the best pizza imaginable. Basically all the food is... great and since everything can be customized, you can't go wrong. First time visiting this specific take-out location and thestaff was very friendly and overall happy. The place was very clean and my large order was actually ready a few minutes earlybut was still perfectly heated when I arrived home 20 minutes later. Attached some pics but my family wouldn't wait...lol Read more

Amazing delicious pizza, super cheesy. I had 1 piece and my husband had 2, and we couldn't finish it. Good price. Friendly... people. Must try. Read more