Reviews for Mighty Fine Pizza in Petoskey, MI
We were excited to try after reading so many great reviews. We ordered the BBQ Chicken pizza and cheese sticks. We also asked... for marinara sauce for the cheese sticks. Came out to $39 after tax and we added a $5 tip for the driver. Over an hour later weget get the food. No marinara sauce :( which is a shame because the cheese sticks were dry as chalk and had way too much garlic.Took a bite of the pizza and immediately noticed the marinara sauce was in my BBQ chicken pizza??? I ate 1 slice and was readyto chuck it right back up. The cubed up chicken was barely hot and tasted like chunks of rubber. I check the receipt to see ifmaybe it was wrote on the ticket wrong and also noticed they decided to tip the driver $6 instead of $5? Didn?t bother callingback? Fast forward 6 hours I spent 2 hours on the toilet in the middle of the night and been burping up what I am going to callthe worst pizza I ever ate!!! Read more
Best tasting pizza ever! Delicious crust, crunchy but soft! Very generous toppings sauce is just right! We also ordered cheese... bread. We were going to heat it up when got home to Millersburg for a snack. ???????????????? It never got there. We ate it coldon the way! Read more
Today Mighty Fine Pizza made a minor error on our order and they went above and beyond to fix it. Their kindness, along with... their good food, will keep us coming back for more. Thank you! Read more
Fast, on-time, yummy pizza every single time. Their "Family Special" for $38.50 is pretty awesome. It's enough food for 2 adults... and 3 kids (under 13) plus leftovers. Hard to feed five for under $100 on the town anymore. ?? Read more
Quick and delicious pie. Didn't expect such greatness to come from a "hole in the wall" type of establishment. Walked in to a... friendly greeting. I listened to young staff discuss and care about their deliveries while I waited for my pizza to come fromthe oven. Every interaction with the order from conception to completion depicted the name of the restaurant. Yum! Read more
It's Mighty Fine... but not quite Mighty Good... the service is Mighty Great though I will tell you! Quick friendly and... affordable. Their pizza was pretty good. I got their pizzarito and it was a lot of dough and not much sauce or toppings, on thecontrary their pizza has a little too much sauce but still a fine pizza. Read more
Mighty Fine Pizza is a wonderful little restaurant with fantastic pizzas made in house. I really enjoy their crust. What makes... them even better is the ability to buy pizza dough from them, so you can make your own pizza at home. I ended up getting amedium pizza and pizza dough to freeze and use later. This is the pizza I made with their dough. It's the only place in the areaI want to eat pizza from starting now. :D Great job, guys! Read more
Tiny, tiny, tiny space so absolutely no eat in ????. We stopped to pick up pizza and wings for our overnight stay in Petoskey.... Friendly staff for sure, thanks for the smiles guys! We ordered a meat pizza with thin crust...tasted great, nothingspectacular but it's have it again for sure. The wings not so much in my opinion. We ordered buffalo and it had a differentkind of spice that I couldn't put my finger on the name but I didn't care for it. Honestly I didn't taste any buffalo atall. If you're adventurous go ahead and try the wings but the pizza is good. Price was average and parking can be tricky ifit's busy. Read more