Reviews for Pizza Cottage in Pickerington, OH
The food and service were excellent. Even when another customer, who let their children run around the restaurant wild, our... waitress dealt with that in a respectful and firm manner. Read more
First time order, usually my friends order always great, my order of 10 wings I get it almost burned n 9 wings n a small piece... of a wing, my pizza dry n barely any meat supposed to be meat lover...I'll probably won't be back Read more
Don't waste the money for appetizers! They've made the portions so small it's a complete ripoff from not even a year ago. They... charge $6.99 for the fried pickles and brought me just ten pickle slices. They charge $5.99 for the loaded fries and without adoubt we got less than half the fries we used to for the same money just a year ago. They still use the same size baskets toserve the food that used to come out full so it's pretty easy to tell how much less food there is. Ten pickle slices for $7.Absolute rip-off. They made the pickle slices a *little* bigger to make it seem like less of a rip-off which just makes itworse! The appetizer used to be plenty for me and my two daughters to share, now it's barely enough for one person for the sameprice. Don't waste the money on appetizers anymore ??????????? We also had to wait a long time for our check, our server didn'tcheck on us for probably 15-20 minutes at the end of our meal. Overall a bad experience. Really unfortunate. Read more
It was just me and my two kids (3 and 6) for a few days on vacation while we waited for the rest of the family to come up. We... went here for dinner and the waitress was so nice to the kids and took extra time to talk to them like they were adults. Thefood was really good. Probably the best pizza we had on vacation. We will absolutely go back Read more
Probably our favorite of the six pizza shops around us, also the most locally run. We love their thin crust, and the BLT pizza... is the most unique item in the pizza world. We order online for takeout and rarely have any issues with it being ready or fresh.We don?t go here often because it is by far the priciest option, but we?re never dissatisfied. Read more
I had their signature PLT sub with crispy pepperoni provolone cheese lettuce roma tomatoes and mayonnaise. It was pretty good.... Correction. There are more than one "signature dishes" on the menu. So when requesting a your "signature dish" make sure youname it. The pictures represent is Ruthie's ways steak sub. I still liked it. Read more
It's been a while since I've had this pizza and unfortunately it's going to be a while before I have it again. The crust very... dry and the sauce tasted sour. The pepperoni was too salty and burnt. The Italian sub was decent but the bread wasn't thesame. Disappointing, because it looked good. Read more
Well, hard to give a review when I never got my order. Going to bed hungry tonight, lol. The 2 bud lights were lovely, though.... Was given the completely wrong order and was looked at like I'm crazy when I sent it back. Manager never even came to apologize. Read more