Reviews for Pie Guy's Pizzeria in Picton, ON
Called to order a pizza they said it would come at 930 so 45 minutes so I said great see you then . 945 comes around 15 minutes... late so I call and politely ask if the pizza was coming soon I then get told it will be another hour for the pizza rudely thenthe lady says we?ll do you want it or not ? There is no where open ! Yes I want it . She hangs up on us ! So rude and horriblecustomer service. As a restaurant owner myself my opinion they should be embarrassed. Read more
We had the chicken parm sandwich, it was very tasty. The garlic bread with cheese is delicious. It will take us at least a... week to finish the panzarotti, they are huge!! We have had their pizza before as well and it?s excellent. The crust isexcellent, the ingredients were fresh. If you are ever in Picton, this is a must try. Read more
We show up late for our pizza pick up... thats on us... but thinking that the pizza would be horrendously undercooked... this is... sticky dough in the photo not melty cheese... absolutely abhorrent meal. Read more
DO NOT EAT HERE!!!This pizza was the worst I have ever eaten in my life. I am really wondering how people have said this is the... best pizza they have ever tasted. The toppings were days old. Mushrooms were like sponges, The meats were dried out and thecheese was sour and smelled. The ranch dipping sauce tasted like vinegar. The center was uncooked. And the entire slice fellapart with ease. And on top of that made us sick the a few hours later. The prices are also ridiculous. The owner laughed sayingI should take a look at his website after telling him how bad his pizza was and coming up with every excuse in the book to tryto pretend that his pizza was the best in the world. Such a sad excuse for a pizza. This guy should be ashamed for giving thistype of product and service to people. Save your money go to 555 down the street. Read more
We are Toronto-nians who own a vacation property near Picton in Prince Edward County. Being foodies from the city, we didn?t... expect to find much locally in terms of gourmet pizza. Pie Guy?s was an awesome and unexpected surprise! Hands-down this is theBEST pizza and pasta joint in town. Awesome pizzas, homemade wings and Cesar salad to rival any steakhouse; all made with realingredients and prepared on-par or better than the best joints in Toronto. Super friendly service can be expected very time! PSdon?t come to this place if your worried about your waste line but definitely come if you want awesome food! Read more
This pizza was truly a work of art. The shaved headed man with the substandard arithmetic skills outdid himself this time.... Typically, cheese has a smooth melted texture and mouthfeel; however, this pizza?s cheese was much more like a flavourful blastof sand which may sound distasteful, but actually added quite a tantalizing depth to the magnificently salacious culinaryadventure I had sojourned this evening. Also, for transparency?s sake, if you happen to stumble across Joey Sabatini?s review,please ignore it. Granted, I?ve never met the man, but I?m fairly confident Joey of Sabatini?s Pizzeria and Hot Tubs (TM)attempted a hostile takeover of the Pie Guy?a pizzeria back in 2009 and has been up to the dastardly machinations of bankruptingevery pizza joint in the tri-county area for the past decade. Read more
Pizza was great! Walked into the dude working using a torch lighter to blacken the top of the pizza, that was perfect! Super... nice guy also. The wings were damn good too. I?ll come here again if I?m in town again. Read more
Visiting from the GTA, our first time in Picton and Pie Guy's. The owner (Jeff) is a gem, and his small shop and take-out window... is adorable. Pizza was great! The CHICKEN WINGS WERE A KNOCK-OUT!!! Like home made, never had wings like this before - a MUSTTRY!!! Read more