Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Pike Creek, DE

Anthony’s hands down has the best service I have ever had. The cauliflower pizza is 10/10 would recommend

We attended a large birthday party dinner here and it took about 30 minutes to get everyone seated. We were elbow to elbow and... it took an hour for food, but the servers were friendly & the food was delicious - even the salad. We had the garlic romanowings and the regular cheese coal-fired pizza, and this was some of the best pizza I've ever had. We'll be back. Read more

Let me say this place runs like a well-oiled machine. I placed an order for takeout and purely for amusement starting counting... up employees. I got to at least 20 and I'm sure lots more back of house. It was well-organized chaos. The pizzas are delicioustoo and ready in no time at all. Everyone was friendly and helpful. And busy! Leave them a big tip, these runners are runningoff their feet. Read more

Always a great experience here, food is excellent and some of the best staff in the area. Just placed a catering order for the... first time and it exceeded my expectations. Samantha made the whole process simple and fast. A few moments after our order wasreceived, we had a follow up call asking how everything was and if there was anything else we needed. The customer service andfood quality here is fantastic…Will definitely be doing more catering orders in the future! Thank you! Read more

Order delivery of Carnivore pizza and 10 wings original. Sad to say the taste did not meet expectations and on this heavy meat... pie the best thing was the meatballs. It’s coal fired but the taste of the crust was just burnt. Portions are good and thewings taste WAY better the 2nd day… I wish it would have lived up to the hype.. Read more

I've never had meatballs on pizza that tasted this good. Normally they're sliced and as a result they're dry- I never knew there... was another way. But with the firmness of a well done, coal fired pizza crust, the stability can sustain full mini meatballs,leaving them moist and juicy and wonderful. I am thrilled to go back for more the next time I am in town!! Read more

The restaurant is a simple setup and clean. The cashier who checked me out was nice. Depending where you sit you can see the... brick fire happening. I had pizza and wasn't anything to write home about (and I love pizza!). Also, disappointed that thecookie and brownie I bought are prepackaged brand that I can purchase anywhere. My sister's arugula pizza was missing requesteditems. The salad and wings ordered were enjoyed by those that ate them. For $90, I would expect more in my desserts andattention paid to the order as a whole. I was there for a fundraiser and I appreciate the community give back. Read more

Very nice place, we were happy to find this one. I've had coal fired pizza in the past and wasn't crazy about it (tasted like,... well, burnt coal) but this pizza was excellent. Great crust and sauce, well balanced by the cheese and pepperoni on ours. Servers were very friendly, good beer selection and lots of variety on the tvs. Read more