Reviews for Panatieri's Piscataway in Piscataway, NJ

When the web site doesn?t list plain Chicago pizza for delivery - you call the pizzeria to find out how to order it plain -... then they tell you to go back to the website - so I said why can?t I place an order - then I?m told ok but there?s no deliveryservice ?. Hmmm good bye Read more

Great food, even better customer service, god bless the Spanish lady that?s always there she?s the reason I love going there.

Best pizza and service in the neighborhood. People working are super friendly and the chef customizes the dishes as you prefer.

This is the best f****** pizza I've ever had in my life. It's crunchy and fluffy at the same time. The sauce isn't heavy, and... you can actually taste every ingredient used in their pizza. Not to mention, it's all hand-made with fresh ingredients. Theirwings are crunchy as well, and they have different flavors. They also have sweet treats like tres leaches, and flan. It's betterthan authentic New York Italian pizza. Read more

Amazing never eating any other pizza everything we ordered was great but that square too die for and excellent and friendly... service highly recommend give them a shot Read more

I was a loyal customer for a few years, but you guys have changed. I ordered a large pie, and that is definitely a medium/small.... $10+ for this small serving of calamari? $31 for burnt mediocre food??? Nawww I?m good. I?ll go somewhere else. Read more

The service here was friendly and top notch. The pizza slices were around $3.79 per slice. A little on the higherend than if... you were to just buy a whole pie. However, the pizza was really good. The crust was thin and I had plenty of chicken on my bbqchicken slice. The others in my group also enjoyed their slices as well. Their slices could be uneven. Some were bigger thanothers so hopefully you get the bigger slice Read more

A very clean, neat place. The staff are very friendly, always smiling, bringing joy to customers. Its not an ordinary pizza... store, they bring ypur order to your table. What I ate is great. Didnt tasted the pizzas because I wanted something differentand was eating pizzas during the week so took another italian entree, and it was worth it. They know what theyre doing and itssatisfying peoples taste buds and exceeding to customers' expectations. I would go there again. Read more