Reviews for Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria in Plainview, NY

My husband and I stopped at this restaurant on the way home without knowing about it and will definitely come back when in... town. DELICIOUS FOOD AND SERVICE, and the chicken noodle soup was also delish and homemade. We highly recommend it.???? Read more

Such a beautiful restaurant! Food was fantastic, service was prompt and courteous too. Owner has a great heart for the... community! We will definitely be back - we are up to at least 6 visits! Read more

Mario's has several very good pizza places but this is their only fine restaurant with white tablecloths. We were there for... dinner. The tables and chairs, and booths were all comfortable. The wines by the glass were good, and better bottles areavailable. The server was experienced. We both had chicken Marsala, our favorite. The food was served hot! The chicken was verytender. There was a lot of sauce and many mushrooms. The sauce made the meal! We took home the leftovers. Read more

The food at Mario's was delicious! We stopped in for lunch and was not disappointed. Dessert was delicious. I will definitely... be back. Read more

Our favorite neighborhood Italian restaurant. Out of their several locations in the area, we like this full service sit down... restaurant the most. Spacious interiors, good noise levels (i.e can hear each other), excellent service. We love the food fromMario's, dining in makes it more enjoyable. Read more

Was ok. Service was nice. Atmosphere was nice. Food was a bit of a letdown. This was our first time here, but it would not be... a "go back to" place. Food was not BAD, just not great. My chicken was paper thin and dry/way overcooked (if you're going topound/slice it thin, you gotta REALLY watch it when you cook it.). Had to hunt around a bit to find flavor - not subtle, justmissing. Eggplant was ok - again, flavor a bit lacking (better than chicken dish though). Fried squid seemed fresh made, but abit oily and the coating kept falling off (got to get it somewhat dry before coating it, or it won't stick well). Looked nicein plate. To be clear, nothing was bad, and we ate everything either there or next day. I would just try another place nexttime. Dinner was about $50 for one appetizer and two dinners. Read more

Delicious food. Nice atmosphere. Very good service. Pretty good size of portions. It was a lovely experience to try this place... on my way home. Read more

The food is great here and so is the service! I love the Mario's restaurant. The owner is so kind and funny as well. I always... feel welcome here. Today I went in the morning and they baked me a fresh buffalo chicken roll which is amazing! I asked to havegarlic butter put on top and they did it with a smile! The owner even said that I gave him ideas. I will most definitely bereturning often. The food quality is amazing. Read more