Reviews for J Timothy's Taverne in Plainville, CT
Went here for the legendary wings and we were not disappointed. They were absolutely delicious. We also got some tater tot... poutine which was awesome --- good gravy and good curds. The restaurant is gigantic, but they're busy because of how amazing thefood it Read more
I've heard only positive things about J Timothy's. I went with really high expectations. Everyone mentioned that there would... most likely be a wait to be seated. However, we walked in and were seated right away. The waitress came by soon after. I knew wehad to get the Dirty wings. I can't recommend that enough. They're so crispy and flavorful. Best wings I've had. I wish they hadmore sauce options. Previously, I've gone to Dew Drop Inn which has a crazy selection of sauces. J Timothy just cooks the wingsup so nicely. Aside from the wings, definitely recommend the French onion soup! Two thumbs up on the entire experience. Read more
I try to grab some J Tim?s whenever I pass plain I?ll or nearby. The wings here, are the best I?ve ever had. The dirt style... wings are elite. My favorite sauce is the Honey Gold. Do not hesitate getting yourself a wing or 2, or even a bucket like meevery time I grab takeout! Read more
We were really happy with the food and service! We tried the honey gold dirty wings and the teriyaki dirty wings. The honey gold... was our favorite flavor, teriyaki was a bit spicy and dry. Next time we are going to try them not dirty as they seemed a bit toodried out. The surprising and unfortunately disappointing thing was that the wings were not hot. They were tepid intemperature. We also got the massive pretzel and we couldn?t decide which we liked better, the honey mustard sauce or thecheddar ale that came with it. We also had the mozzarella fritta. This was my favorite. The marinara and pesto sauces on thecrispy, lightly fried mozzarella were delicious! And, being a Harry Potter fan, I had to try the Harry?s Butter Beer. Ourwaitress asked if I liked sweets and I do! But it was kind of her to warn me because it?s quite sweet. One note of caution: stirit first. I took a sip and the first swallow was warm and pure alcohol. It is much better when mixed. The restaurant was quitebusy, but the staff kept up well with the service. The floors were quite littered with French fries and other bits, but Iimagine there?s no way to keep up the pace and tidy up too. Had it been cleaner and the wings hot, this would have been a 5 starreview. Read more
During a recent visit to CT, my host recommended we go to what is one of the top-5 rated wing joints in the country. They double... fry their wings which is part of how they manage such a big crunch on their skin. We ordered a bucket of the buffalo and 10 ofthe red chili. The red chili is highly underrated...they were absolutely fantastic. Sticky, packed with flavor with a nicebalance of sweet and spice. The buffalo, well, they're easy to eat a pile of, but the flavor leaves a bit to be desired. Theflavor of the wing and skin though are beyond excellent. Two complaints I had, but neither involving the food: only 1 cider ontap (Downeast Strawberry) & the A/C, or A/C pipe that was above our booth was dripping condensation onto the seat. It was ascorcher of a day though, so that bad boy was working you knew. Overall, this place lives up to the hype...a must stop for anywing fan. Read more
I have gone to J Timothy's a few times & they have never disappointed. Their Buffalo chicken wings flavor is DELICIOUS & so is... their Honey BBQ, Flavor. Best wings I have tried. I also tried their Mac & Cheese but that has been a hit or miss. Tried it on 3separate occasions and on 2 of those occasions it was bland, I believe it depends on who's cooking it. Place is normally packedwhich shows how good their food is. Staff have been friendly & accommodating. Place is definitely worth the trip. Read more
I have been here more than a handful of times and that?s not an exaggeration. Never have I ever been disappointed. They have by... far the best wings I have ever had bar none. Their ?dirt? wings are extravagant. This place is always busy so definitely need toeither go late or wait but no matter what it is worth it. I believe they only take reservations for parties of 7 or more. Read more
JTT was recommended to me as soon as I got into town and it did not disappoint. Of course we had to try the dirty wings and they... live up to the hype for sure. Solid beer list, very comfortable dining areas, and friendly service - what more do you need? Read more