Reviews for Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Pleasant Valley, NY

First time visit (New to the area). Stopped to order & wait to take out. I sat at the small counter to wait for my order & had a... cup of excellent coffee. Order was ready quickly (less than 10 minutes) and all of the employees were extremely friendly andhelpful. Spotted some cheesecake in a display & added it to my order at the last minute. The food items (Greek salad and chickenparm wedge) were both excellent and the cheesecake was out of this world. I'm sure this will become a regular on our take outschedule. Read more

I used to get the dinner size Greek salad with chicken. It was amazing. Recently, the salad I've ordered has been far less... than amazing. I'm not sure what even makes it "Greek". It's nothing more than a tossed salad with a sprinkling of Feta cheese. Last night I tried again. I ordered a $6.95 Greek salad/no chicken, extra olives and Feta. OMG, the extra olives turned outto be THREE IN TOTAL and I got a small cup with a tablespoon of "extra Feta". For all that EXTRA, I got charged over $11.00!!!!Ridiculous!. Read more

I had an amazing meal. I was dithering on which dinner to get, but I'm happy to have chosen what I did. I would enjoy going back... again. The prices were a little high, but then again, where isn't that the case anymore. My only food complaint is that theyserve those large flat fries with the meal. Don't get me wrong... those ones are great when making a fancy fry plate like theGreek Fries they served. But as a side with only ketchup to fancy they up, they fall a bit flat. The thinner, crisper ones arefar superior. The only reason I couldn't give this place 5 stars was the bathroom situation. While it was very clean, it wasunfortunately not wheelchair accessible. It's a little harsh to lose a full star over this, but Google won't let me take offonly half. Everything else, from the staff to the food was amazing. Read more

I remember coming to this restaurant in my late teens. They have been in business for over forty years and have three... locations.. The pizza here is excellent. They offer hot and cold sandwiches/heroes, soups , platters and salads. They make theirown salad dressing and tomato sauce and bottle and sell it in their restaurants. Prices are average and service is friendly. Allthree locations have always been extremely clean. Service has always been friendly. After COVID prices increased sharply. Read more

Stick to the pizza and forget the rest of the menu. I hear the pizza is good although I've never tried it; there certainly were... plenty of people eating it in the restaurant and picking it up to go. As far as my dining experience went it was pretty bad. Iordered lasagna which came in a casserole dish and just barely resembled lasagna. Instead of layers of pasta with ricotta cheeseand sauce, this was essentially lasagna pasta in almost a tomato like soup with a big melted chunk of mozzarella on top. Myfriend ordered salmon which came with mashed potatoes and steamed vegetables. Unfortunately the water from the vegetables wasall over the plate drowning/ruining the mashed potatoes. The salmon wasn't very good nor were the vegetables. The bread thatcame with the meal was also dry and stale tasting. As I said earlier, just order pizza and you'll probably be ok. Whatever youdo don't order anything else or you'll probably be very sorry you decided to eat that night. I definitely do not recommend thePleasant Valley location. I have eaten at Four Brothers in Amenia a few years back and had baked ziti and it was pretty good.Not sure if there was a change or just a difference between locations. Read more

One of the best pizza i ever had? the brothers pizza pie is the best pizza in new york.. very clean & modern decor?

Have been coming here for upwards of 30 years, my family use to have a house by Hunns Lake and my fondest memories were always... stopping at Four Brothers and sitting in a booth and eating their amazing pizza! Time has passed and that house is gone, I nowlive in Brooklyn but every opportunity that I get to return(hikes, fair, wedding) upstate I stop here for one of the bestpizza's I?ve ever had(and trust me I?ve eaten a lot). Highly recommend Read more

First time there was in 1980, and boy have the Four Brothers aged well! Pizza and Greek salad better than I remembered and the... interior decor made for a nice and pleasant dining experience. Thank you, Four Brothers, for remaining consistently good, andfor being a high light of my Pleasant Valley reunion. Read more