Reviews for Casey's in Pleasantville, IA
Went in for lunch since it is the only place in town to eat that is open for lunch on Mondays. Asked about getting a sub and... was rudely told by cashier that it had to be ordered online. Was then told that even if I ordered it online, it would still bea 30 minute wait. Never been to a caseys that you HAD to place your order online. Will definitely not be back in this storeagain. Read more
I've lived here in Pleasantville for almost 3 years. Consistently the pizza is an issue. Multiple return visits to get it fixed... due to missing toppings or toppings we didn't order or too many onions to where it's overpowering. Tonight we decided to try thenew BBQ Chicken pizza. What a disappointment. I figured a BBQ pizza would have BBQ sauce on it (at least more than a drop ortwo). And I think there was chicken and bacon but the overpowering taste of onions killed any other flavor. And just look at thepizza itself. Aren't pizzas supposed to round and not looking like someone threw the dough at the wall first? Read more
Bad experience. Called at 8 for 1 large pepperoni pizza 35 min wait. Ok no problem showed up at 8:30 pizza was not ready said it... will be another 15 min. Ok no problem. Waiting another 15 min as I walk back in the clerk says oh she just put it in... Are youkidding me.. Now it 9:00 and I just got my pizza maybe they need more help idk Read more
I mean it's Casey's. You can't go wrong stopping here. Gas, food, munchies, funny guy behind the counter always makes me laugh.... I will drive extra out of my way just to go to a Casey's when I'm on the road. Also, the bathrooms are almost always clean Read more
Horrible customer service, call for an hour straight trying to order pizza and they don't know how to answer their phone, and... out of curiosity went and stood by the kitchen and called the store and they just ignored the phone ringing in which I'm callingthen casually walks over to the phone and picks up after two minutes of ringing and hangs it right back up. Will be reportingkitchen staff to corporate cause fortunately enough for me I know a few people in the corporate office. If you can't answer aphone then go find an office job where you can be lazy and get paid for it. Read more
This Casey's is great at everything except putting food in the warmers that people like. Often there is no food at all. They... put the strangest combinations of toppings on the warmer pizza, seemingly so they don't have to cook more. Read more
Great donuts. Butterscotch is very good. Staff doesn't seem to know how to run a 4th grade lemonade stand much less one of the... busiest Casey's around. I think we could replace the staff with trained miniature horses and Orangutans and it would run moreefficiently. I would petition the management to try this. Try the pizza! Read more
The restrooms were nice and clean. Good ready to eat food in the case, like wraps and little packs of apples and cheese.