Reviews for Casey's in Plymouth, IN
Excellent food and service
Always fast, friendly and fully stocked.
Definitely the best pizza around! I use the app and take advantage of all the awesome freebies along with fuel points. The pizza... is fresh and the staff is very friendly. Download the app and start saving today! Read more
Always a clean and friendly gas station. Their pizza is great. Would choose it over Pizza Hut or Papa John's any day
I love their breakfast pizza and I order it often, but the older woman who makes the pizza and hands it out is the rudest... person. She always mumbles under her breath and sighs loudly as if working there is the worst thing she's ever dealt with. Shenever thanks me and rolls her eyes a lot. The rest of the staff had always been more than pleasant! Read more
They have seemed to stop delivering completely. Trying to order online is a brick wall. That was basically the only time I... shopped with them, so at this point they don't really serve a purpose for me. The food is "ok" and the service is fine, but thebiggest benefit was them being able to deliver and they don't do that anymore. Read more
Love the pizza but they are supposed to deliver till 9:30 but when I called at 8:56 they said they already took the trash out... and wouldn't deliver because someone decided to shut down before they were supposed to Read more
Their pizza is awesome!!