Reviews for Keith's Pizza & Calzones in Plymouth, NH
Pizza was not good at all. Ordered the mac and cheese pizza and it looked like Kraft mac and cheese put onto pizza crust. The... meatballs on the other pizza looked and tasted like they were microwaved. Very disappointed. Will not be returning. If I couldgive it a zero I would. Read more
As someone who has worked at multiple pizza places, I can say, this is hands down the best pizza in Plymouth. Smaller menu but... allows them to focus on what they do and they do it well. Would be 5 stars but they close shop when the college isn't in. Read more
I live in RI, and visiting up in Lincoln and Brettonwoods. I was reading the reviews. I think it is best we don't eat at this... joint of a place!!!! I am not going to ignore the red flags. OH!!!! by the way pick up your phones. Read more
So excited to have Keith's Pizza and Calzone's open again. I have really missed the food but most of all I have missed the... staff. Christine is amazing and always very pleasant. Even though they have to wear a mask now. They all do it with pride(evenin a hot kitchen).. Thank you Keith's Pizza staff for all you do Read more
25 MAIN ST is the new address for Keith's Pizza & Calzones. Arguably the best pizza in Plymouth, NH. Lost a star because it... took 6 calls to get through. Also, order online doesn't work either. Pizza was ready in 20 like they promised. Good value forthe money. Read more
came in 1:00 Am really hungry. ordered a large bacon pepperoni pizza and a side of jalapeño poppers. food came out at 1:25 and... was hot and fresh food was good. but the marinara sauce was cold! other than that really good pizza. they deliver too! they alsohave computers here. Read more
Eating a small calzone with veggies and garlic with a side of marinara sauce yummy. The sauce is awesome it dont hurt the belly... like a lot of pizza restaurants have. Later your reaching for a tums or mylanta lols. This pizza restaurant is not like thosedominos or pizza hut. The only other pizza places I like are more where I live, but when in Plymouth New Hampshire I choose thisfriendly restaurant for sure 100%. Recommended to eat at w friends or family. Setting is relaxing and inviting and comfortable.Try it out when you visit there. Read more
Very average and oily but we are in New Hampshire I'm not sure if there is many places within an hour that is better.