Reviews for Thatcher McGhee's Pompton Lakes in Pompton Lakes, NJ
Been coming here for a good decade now and don't live in Jersey so that should tell you something. As a bar, it's great. Typical... Irish style pub, typical North Jersey vibes, great people frequent it and I've never not had a good time. As a restaurant,delicious. They have so many good things on the menu, a lot of authentic Irish stuff, a lot of "modern" or American food. TheThatch fries are an obvious thing to get. The bangers and mash are fantastic, imo. The Guinness stew is very good too and so isthe Shepherds Pie. Read more
My family has dined at Thatchers over the past couple of years and all of our meals have been delicious but recently we have... noticed the use of not so fresh ingredients. Canned mushrooms were a bit disappointing in a chicken dish and possibly frozenvegetables in a salmon dish. For the price they are charging, I?m not so happy ???? Read more
We just had the BEST experience here taking my dad out with the whole family for Father's Day! Everything we ordered was... delicious! The Irish fare was by far the best I've ordered out and all of the other appetizers and meals we ordered wereamazing! Love the environment and our waitress Ella completed the whole package! She was so pleasant and catered to the needsof all 9 of us! We live a half hour away and will DEFINITELY be back! Read more
If you feel like traveling back to Ireland this is the place to be! The food is excellent, the atmosphere authentic and the... staff friendly. We really enjoyed it! Read more
We came in from PA and came to your restaurant, the food was out of this world. We ordered 2 Fish and Chips, 1 Cheeseburger and... fries, a Ruben, and a Sirloin Tip Sandwich plus appetizers. Everything was amazing. We really liked you Beer and Cheddar cheesesauce fir the German Pretzels Bites. We will be back everything was AWESOME!!!! Debbie B from Muncy PA I?m sorry I didn?t takepictures of the rest kcal the food! Read more
Good selection of food. Nice atmosphere. Great service.
Really had a great time! The Food! And service was just great!????True Irish ?? fare! It was delicious ???? Kristine was a... really great Bartender, and made excellent recommendations! Such sweet personality! I?ll be back?????????? Read more
We've been long-time patrons of their Denville location which has always been a favorite spot for us. We just by happens chance... found ourselves in Pompton Lakes for a lucky stop for dinner at original Thatchers. We expected nothing less than than theexcellent food and service we received that night. Brian was superb server and we felt right at home. Thatchers will always beone of my favorite go-to spots, a little home away from home. Read more